ZeKayeM vs. MinorThreat

[MinorThreat]

Recently, ZeKayeM totally flamed my beloved siggy for no apparent reason. SO to make him eat his words I askyou: WHO'S IS BETTER?

HIs:

Mine:

[MartinBabies]

Your sign is teh win! Even tough I don't like the render so much (too many details for me) it's still better.

[Dale]

I prefer yours, it's more orignal , and has more charecteristic Nice job ^.^

[weasel]

MinorThreat has a better one.

[phoenixmaster]

Yours better, obviously.

And this is exactly why i dislike giving critique on others sigs... cuz i cant do better! :P lol

[Twan]

MinorThreat, yours I like more, but I don't like its size. I like the render....a lot though.

[MinorThreat]

i don't understand why everybody h8s my big sig so much, gives me more room to work...

[Dale]

Sigs aren't meant to be big.. they're meant to be a small peice of work with only the best. But yours is one of the only big sigs i like ^.^

[weasel]

One of the only doesn't make sense... why does everyone use it?!

I think big sigs are ok. I just hate it when you can see their image ended about 100px lower but their image is 500px instead of 400px. It just takes up space!

[Twan]

Smaller signatures can prove you are a better graphic designer. It gives you less space to work with, and if you can make it look good, it is better than a larger sized signature. They also just look plain better.,