New and old sig

[Killer]

This is my updated one, I cropped as much as possible and added a grid




This was my old one






What looks better?

[D.Sobers]

I say your old one looks better. Grids dont look good in all pics. (Grid kills it)

Nice try tho -
New 1: 5.5/10
Old 1: 7/10

[Oblivion]

Your quote is in horrible position, and yeah, the grid does kill it. For your quote, try putting a 1px black stroke around it. It will bring it out and make it look alot cleaner. Old- 7 New-5.5

[MinorThreat]

actually, I like the grid. but holy hell, DO SOMETHING ABOUT THOSE FONTS! comic sans is posibly the worst font for a sig like that.

<oh yea, and horrible quote placement>

No excessive exclamation points