SOTW #56 Voting

[carrotderek]

Good turnout ja?

Poll closes in 7 days.

[Samuel]

Not to seem like an asshole or anything, but I don' think any of these deserve a vote. (MOST) hardly relate to the theme, and I think alot of these should have been discluded from voting.

BESIDES that, lol, I think danielsaso deserved my vote. =P

[Jeff]

Toshiyan, only held back by a few minor issues. I do agree with bfg about the lack of relation to the theme on some of them, but I think that's fine, good to see a great variety of interpretations.

[carrotderek]

I somewhat agree Sam, many of these are just renders slapped on, not much artistic interpretation of the theme. I will let this slide for the voting for this SOTW, but in the future I will be more strict.

[Horus]

i liked toshiyans and danielsaso most
but i went with toshiyans because i like the depth and the colours
sorry dan, yours is pretty too

[phantamines]

um, maybe it was a bit too broad? i wanted to animate mine again, and i really liked my butterfly, so i used it (tho it felt more like a proof of concept to me). personally Jsooiah's i really like.

[jeebin]

jsooiah's is pretty

lol

i love it

but i understand...the content of the sigs shoulda been much better

[carrotderek]

Broad = good.

Just an over-reliance on renders to convey the theme instead of creating it for themselves.

[Apprentice.]

chivalry for me i love that sig! it was either chivalry or tyson

[danielsaso]

yeah they should have taken away or sth those that dont fir but anyway, good luck everyone