Rate my siggs

[Sumomo]

Hi! I've only been dabling in photoshop for a couple of months... So I'm not really very good yet ....

Please rate these siggs..
And PLEASE tell me which one you like the best

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6. And of course the signature I have below .....

[robgasm]

not too keen on anime but the bgs are good apart from the 2nd

the font effects etc arent that good but they alright

overall 7.3/10 ( dont wory that means they good with me )

[AcidGlow]

My only comment is you leave too much open space. The rest is fine. Good work.

[MinorThreat]

avg=7.0/10

they are kind of all the same

my fav=3

[robgasm]

o sorry, my fav either 4 or 3

[angryjohnny]

Really good work for someone who has only been working a few months in photoshop.. way better than the stuff I was creating in my early days.

I like number 1.. Not only did you do a nice job making her seem part of the background ( Nice blending job ) but her demeanor seems to go along with the the background and whole feel for the sig. Number 5 is very good regarding the same notes I made about number one, And I really like the text you chosed " come with me" But I think you can do a better job with the fonts and look of the text.. maybe try and make it look alittle more hmm... Joyful ( just to go along with the statment).. maybe warm colors and enlarging the text so it makes more of a statment... and a little more color to the sig itself and I think you have another great sig. I like the sig you use as well.. has a nice feel to it.. Great work!

[jerner]

I like the 3rd one, it's simple but goodlooking. Since you've only worked with photoshop for a couple of month I think you have done a good job, but as said, too much open space, (only on some of them) keep it up.

[Haven]

guessing you don't have a girlfriend....just anime!....just kiddin...backgrounds are pretty cool..

[Nightfire]

[One] I like the color blending with the anime and background, I don't really like the glow on her though. Animtaion on text is a bit skippy. Really like the border.

[Two] Like the anime you used, your background is good but since it's a background you could cut a part away and it would look the same(meaning repeated background) You should work on filling more space, like your text is small you should enlarge it a bit.

[Third] I really like how this one fits. Only text size bugs me, you should make it a bit bigger. I like though that you have a background that is a picture itself so not an empty looking area.

[Fourth] The background is a little to strong brushed? I don't know how to explain that. Anyway your anime pic just is way to smooth for the background. The text is also to hard to read.

[Fifth] Your anime pic looks a little streched sideways and the background you can barely see. I like the chose of text you used but I think you should have placed it in another place.

Overall I really like your sigs gj expecially for just a few months.

[2-intenze]

i like the 4th the most good brushing and a good choise of the render

(8/10)