kanye & usher

[Plastic Whore]

there they are.
i intended for one of them to be an sotm entry on another forum, and i chose the kanye one.
i'm still up for ratings/critique though.

[wfcamb]

Top one has some cool effects, but seems like it's a bit empty.. Second one, I've never understood that repeated edge that you have on the right side. I think you can make it much better if the repeat were not there, but then again.. I'm not the expert at sig creations..

Both of them has some nice stuff though, so good work on that..

[Plastic Whore]

it's since your stock doesn't fit on the canvas you selected, so you just duplicate a good part of it and put it in the blank space. and then again it looks cool too x]

[Papa]

First sig seems really really empty besides the cool effect by the render. Also IMO this sig would benifit from a bit of text.
It also needs a light source. Your render has such strong highlights parts of his head are white. Theres no reason to not haver a lightsource when you have such a dark sig with such prominent highlights.
But you have some awesome eeffects going and your coloring is great.

The usher sig I'm not a fan of. It seems like there is just a ton of c4d's as your effects. I don't see much else. Also it needs a bit more contrast.
The pen tooling is pretty cool and I rather like the little rectangle on the right edge.

Gj but you rly should work contrast, Bg and text.