sig Critique plz?

[Newton]

can u guys critique my gibson sig i made.........tell me if its any good and what im missing or what i can add thx

[OptiMAT Prime]

I dunno, it's nice and i like the colours but it's too hard to tell the guitar's shape, which is kind of important

[Deco]

Personally I like it, I like the effect of it smashing and then shattering into little tiny pieces. Good job =) But i do also agree to Optimat

[elixile]

Yeah, add some definition to the edges. But not too much though, we still want it to blend in. Darkening the Top Left and Bottom Right corners would give it more depth.

[Newton]

i tried to fix the sig and make the guitar more clearer....can u tell me if i ruined the sig?......and how did i do on the car sig

[Papa]

not bad on the first sig. good effects and flow and the text is nice. I liek the definition you gave it too.

The second on is okay,. IMO popout sigs are a bit old and i dislike them. The effects are nice but i dont like the blue splatteds on the part of the car thats coming out. it just looks weird. Maybe if they were brown instea of blue.

Text is nice but get it out of that corner. Move it to the center it'd be 100 times better.

[Newton]

how about now i change the splatters to brown and moved the text

[Bloodshed]

i think the guitar is way too blended in.....tooo much blueeee haha, i like the bg and text is not horible but try to make the render stand out more, theres too much blending going on...good job overalll