Naruto Series of Sigs

[Kinetics]

Okay, i am making a Naruto series, my Naruto series started with the Gaara sig a couple days ago, and now i have a Zabuza sig. Rate it and give teh CnC's! Also dont be afraid to be harsh, i know i am not the best at sig making, but i will never be if people dont tell me what i am doing wrong, im not that advanced and am trying to make my own style, and this is what i have gotten. Also i realize that a lot of people make smudge sigs, but this is where i am at in my GFX career so. . .yeah!

[Genisphere]

nice sigs i like the backgrounds just try blending your render in more with with your signatures blurring and sharpening you sort of had it going on your second one but not enough for me anyways the text is alright it's readable but it's not my favorite but hey your not doing this to please me ^^ nice work k.i.u.

[Eralebus]

They look good for smudge tags, they're just lacking depth which can be made in numerous amounts of ways.
Keep in mind when your making them, that there's a foreground, middle ground and background, and everything in-between. If you want to stick with just using the smudge tool, get some splatter brushes and use them with the smudge tool and just mess with the brush settings, and experiment