I need some judement on my signature?

[Carlos_Delva]

Ok this is my third signature ?
Whats wrong with it?
What to do next time?
1-10 for it bein my third sig ?

Tell me everything wrong with it so that I can do better :3
Be harsh ! Mean! Be Simon!

[Genisphere]

it's just really plain and basic so much gradient empty space there just not doing anything for your siganture so this doesn't pop he has lighting on his face to use that lighting make there be a reason he's where sunglasses ya know? this is very nice for you third tag better than what mine was when i first started but just continue reading tutorials learn things and bring that knowledge into your next signature you make bring some flow some depth and blending and most of all use your imagination. Don't be afraid to try new things and if it doesn work out the first time edit it get more c&c or bring that knowledge to your next piece keep it up!

[sirenzo]

i would try using a smoother cut render less u trying to make it like it has ridged lines and more abstract but i would blend focal in more kiu

ps i would also try making the canvas smaller not so long so u get rid of all that other empty space .