there they are.
i intended for one of them to be an sotm entry on another forum, and i chose the kanye one.
i'm still up for ratings/critique though.
04-27-2008, 08:24 AM
wfcamb
Top one has some cool effects, but seems like it's a bit empty.. Second one, I've never understood that repeated edge that you have on the right side. I think you can make it much better if the repeat were not there, but then again.. I'm not the expert at sig creations.. ;)
Both of them has some nice stuff though, so good work on that.. ;)
04-27-2008, 08:33 AM
Plastic Whore
it's since your stock doesn't fit on the canvas you selected, so you just duplicate a good part of it and put it in the blank space. and then again it looks cool too x]
04-27-2008, 08:43 AM
Papa
First sig seems really really empty besides the cool effect by the render. Also IMO this sig would benifit from a bit of text.
It also needs a light source. Your render has such strong highlights parts of his head are white. Theres no reason to not haver a lightsource when you have such a dark sig with such prominent highlights.
But you have some awesome eeffects going and your coloring is great.
The usher sig I'm not a fan of. It seems like there is just a ton of c4d's as your effects. I don't see much else. Also it needs a bit more contrast.
The pen tooling is pretty cool and I rather like the little rectangle on the right edge.