SOTW 122 Voting!

Good luck to all. The topic was Real people. Remember vote for the sig and not the person.

Voting ends: Sunday June 8, 08 Afternoon CST.

Good luck.

Edit: I had to disqualify Splendid, Ronin, and Ultima's sigs because they did not follow the limitations.
Remember, you MUST adhere to the size limitations, no larger than 400 x 200.

ratchet gmv..it was simple and effective..aristos was good too
good job all of you for entering.

Thanks Immortal, I was wanting to actually do a sig for sotw that was actually worth time, and who knew that Real People was a good one to start on.

Though I am still confused if I am able to vote since I entered.

sizes slightly greater than these limits are acceptable however.

my sig was 420x130 i thought that was slightly larger, but o well. good luck to all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RONIN

sizes slightly greater than these limits are acceptable however.

my sig was 420x130 i thought that was slightly larger, but o well. good luck to all.

---

I knew this would come up. When i was disqualifying i reviewed the rule. I am thinking we need to change it, or we need to make the sizes a bit bigger.

Ronin: I decided to not use that rule for one simple reason. Well it's kind of hard to explain so I'm going to use an example.

Ronin lets say you make a tag that is 420x130.
I make a tag that is 440x130.
I get disqualified because obviosuly my size limit is not slightly greater than the limit, it's a lot greater. However you get to stay in it. However MY sig was only 20 px bigger than yours, which would be (if i let your sig not be disqualified) only slightly larger than your sig.
My sig would be 20 px larger than yours. How am I to draw the line right after you and say even though your sig is only SLIGHTLY larger than ronin's i can't let you enter even though his is only slightly smaller.

Ugh. in short term, I think it's unfair to draw the line at a certain spot after the limit, I can garuntee i have a different idea of slightly larger.

Just so you know I thought slightly larger was about at the absolute most 10 px. ANd tehre is the problem, people's thought's on slightly larger are different. It's pretty much everybodies different connotation of slightly. Which is why i apologize, because depending what everyone elses connotation of slightly is, I could be in the wrong, however i just use the best discretion to decide it.

I'm going to be changing the rules soon if it is okay with the rest of staff. It's just too vague and needs to be updated.

P.S. - to make sure this doesn't happen again ronin, just try and get closer to the sig limit. But again I apologize because due to my connotation of slightly i could be very wrong.

I remember making an entry for this. :confused:

thnx papa, but you dont need to apologize, i totaly understand were ya comin from. i think we should remove the slightly larger bit, and just make it simple. i hope i didnt cause any trouble. thnx.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ultima

I remember making an entry for this. :confused:

---

Read the top, you were disqualified because it didn't follow the sig size rule.

Ronin: it is no problem at all and in fact I am glad you brought it up, as I have been thinking of modifying the rules for awhile now, and this gives me further reason to.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Papa

Read the top, you were disqualified because it didn't follow the sig size rule.

Ronin: it is no problem at all and in fact I am glad you brought it up, as I have been thinking of modifying the rules for awhile now, and this gives me further reason to.

---

Yea I noticed it after I posted. Mine was like 430x220.

lol <3 jorrne's.