Wich is better?...little help

Please tell me guys wich is better. With or without the glass effect?

With
http://img292.imageshack.us/img292/8912/ratchetg5ya.jpg

Without
http://img292.imageshack.us/img292/4...etglass8vv.jpg

Without for sure imo! :)

can i get more opinions from you?

I'd have to say without imo but im still a n00b at graphics -.-

I just don't think that glass effect goes with that kind of sig

without glass effect imo :)

Without looks better.
Glass-effect just doesn't fit in that sig.

k thanks guys

hmm...maybe without glass slightly

i like the 1st one, i dunno what u guys are talking talking about....