oddworld

which looks better ? with or without teh stock ?

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y20...02000/odd2.png

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y20...002000/odd.png

added v3 .. fixed the black gap

http://www.greycobra.com/forums/uplo...1131935829.png

i cant decide both look iight

I think it looks more original w/o the render. Plus the render kinda ruins it, so go for v1

I like it with the render, but the blue on the side of the guy on the right kills it.

i like it without the render, it makes it look like more is going on

The far left of the sig is sex, but then i dont like it, the first 1 looks really weird, i say on the second one, erase the guy on the left and then it wil be sexy

first is better, i love it lol i hate that render though

thanks guys .. tried what u said reflux but it didnt look to good .. anyway fixed the black gap .. v3 added

I like them both a lot. The bg is rather nice itself, and you dont really need a render in there (regardless of whether it fits in good or not, which it does).

Classy colors too.

use #1. That black is great, it adds depth and contrast between both sides, rather than just all filled.