Should I Use this as my new Sig?

http://xs28.xs.to/pics/05192/New-Sig1-WEB-Fix.gif
Which do you prefer, This one or my Curent Sig?

EDIT...Oops forgot to show the Avatar
http://xs28.xs.to/pics/05192/New-Sig1-Avatar-WEB.gif

well euh, i would take the one you maded (in you're post)

but it dont have a border,but make it a little lighter and it will be good and blend the render under the green :)