New one. Keep render?

New one I may just take out the render I can decide if I like it.
http://img187.imageshack.us/img187/2849/sig190xx.gif

Yeah you might want to take out the render but even if you dont it looks good.

The render doesn't look like it fits on right. Maybe if you had desaturated it and colored it with the background it'd look better. Also, I think you should change the outerglow to a different color. Other than that, I think it looks pretty good.

the render absolutely doesnt fit in there. anyways the render looks weird xD his eyes looks huge. owh and u might wanna edit the blending options on your text try what unearth suggested. nice job m8

if u was to keep the render id transform it n switch it horizontly (however its spelt lol) so hes pointing towards text

Does this one look any better?
http://img45.imageshack.us/img45/6952/sig1827es.gif

And this is what it looks like w/ no render...
http://img191.imageshack.us/img191/2020/sig1837je.gif

aww dam whats he called, i love him he's cool, anywho that render of him (electric guy) looks better :)

Raiden :D

they all look ok to me, id say the very first render over the other, but i also like it w.o a render, if you keep it w.o a render then replace that outer glow with a stroke, and change its opacity a bit. The text stands out too much right now i think.

the 2d render looks so much better the the 1st but theres still something that doesnt go right. the text is kool but a bit hard to read. it needs a better border and the man in the 2d sig is to see-thru. other then that the bg is quite good.