Rate the signature above you.

3/10. The render and the image effect you gave to it is the only saving grace. The blending and background kills it for me.

4/10. I don't this this one is much better. :/

i really like teh Mirror's edge one 8/10
for the orce 7/10

a solid 7/10 from me

9/10 love it

effects are too chaotic, work on more flow and composition. 3/10

7/10.

6/10 for both of them

6/10 Kiu :)

hmm not really feeling it sorry 5/10

like this
nice atmospher, good colors and lighting
really like this 9/10

Both 3.5/10

I like the colours, they fit well.
7/10

7/10 needs more flow and face is oversharpened :)
6/10

6/10 love flow but text bugs me and a little dark
8/10 again like the flow but if your text was a bit better would be a 10 atleast a 9

5/10
sorry man
i like the color choices but the sig itself is rather unexciting for me
to many conflicting aspects for me that don't blend well

ya I was trying some stuff I used to do but im really rusty haha

5/10. I like the cleaness of it, but the text is awful and the background is pretty boring.

5/10 not much to it kinda like the flow of the purple


I changed things about the last sig better now?

5/10
5/10

1st, Effect's color's could be blended. To make it better, text and scanlines could be placed better. so um 5/10 couldda been a great sig.
2nd Nice way to use c4ds, but make depth/focal. Better text too.
6/10 keep it up.

6/10. Oversharpened and I don't like how small the render is.
8/10. I love the lighting but it's a little boring. Pretty sleek though.

5/10not much to it kinda like the flow of the purple

5/10 not much flow in this one and text is kinda bad but for some reason i like the grassy look =)

6/10
the blackness stands out too much in a seeming bright piece for me,
this idea was executed well in this piece imo

also though intriguing the text doesn't seem to fit either

6.5/10
I do like the smudge effects you made, the blending is pretty good.
But the render looks lq to me and that kinda ruins the tag IMO.
I also think the left side of the sig is a bit empty.

7.5/10
Nice sig :) I like the feeling of it.
Simple but nice IMO.
The render could be blended a bit more.

10/10. You don't see many sigs that are this good.

ok... starting left from to right

4/10 effects arent that good :/
4/10 smudge in the background isnt good and kinda ruins it
6/10 looks pretty good, theres a consistent flow but it could use some more effects, good light source also :D

fail/10
lol

6/10

7/10 like it man :)

i like the top one.. maybe 6/10
but the bottom one the colors dont look so good, 4/10

7/10 Pretty simple, but really pretty.

5/10 for all

4/10
6/10.

to Buckley

I would say 6 for both I like the top one better just like the style and feel of the sig better.
but decent sig's over all =)

4/10. I think it had potential.
4/10.

to Marz:

8/10, I think its pretty sick. ;)
6/10, I think the bluring on his back is a little much. still a nice sig.

6/10
6/10
Guys this is called rate the sig above you not rate who evers sig you want...

8/10 Awesome smudge and overall effects, but the text need some work IMO.
8/10 Colors are nice, but the bubble effect just doesn't fit..

3/10.
5/10.
They are both really, really hot. But kinda boring as far as design goes.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GFXDub

6/10

Guys this is called rate the sig above you not rate who evers sig you want...

---

Only skipped Runningman because i just rated him. :rolleyes:

5/10 for all.

6/10
6/10