Rate the signature above you.

5/10, lighting is good, you got the right idea, but the composition is dull :)

3/10. I really liked the old one.

8/10, 6/10

7/10 love colors and the effects

7.5/10. Pretty rad but there's a few things that could use some work.

8/10 for both.

colors are beautiful on both, although the blending on the blue one puts the second to shame.

6/10.
It's interesting, and very smooth but not really my style.

9/10, its awesome and i want to be able to do something like it... :)
9/10, im a big final fantasy fan :rolleyes:


http://i978.photobucket.com/albums/a...edsufisig2.jpg

5,5/10
Too chaotic on the left. Try and incorporate more flow. Sharpen the focal. Lightsource would help.


5/10
Pretty basic sig. Text is way too big and distracting.

8/10.
I like it a lot but I wish it was black and white, not black and gray. Also, it's Kanye.

8/10
Looks nice, good flow and colors.

7/10
Color's are great, but the C4D's are all yellow, looks too basic.

5.5/10. Just not really digging it.

6/10 - Left
8/10 - Right
Not digging the left one, feel as if you could of done more to it.

Right one blend is well but the background could use a little work done to it.

Other than that KIU :D

I absolutely love it, I haz nothing bad to say about the sig above meh.
9/10

3/10 for all.

i think she's hot and i like the text
but i'm a noob
so 7/10 imo

7/10

Your first one is decent, good flow, text looks pretty nice, you just might want to move it somewhere else.

The little red at the top of her head is annoying though.

6/10

Not feeling this one, too plain and boring. Add some more effects to bring out the focal.

well
6/10 for top
9/10 for bottom

i really love that ur sigs keep it up

He's banned and got no signature so,
0/10!
BOOM

Mm I'm no Signature Expert, but I like...
8/10
Too dark for my liking!

7/10

Need to work on some techniques in the background and work on some of your effects a bit. Try using some Stocks or perhaps some different brushes.

Keep it up dude. :)

First one 5/10,
Second one 10/10, It is mind blowing.

i dont know what to judge on yours, but hopefully your sig will look good and i can give it a 10/10!

6/10

5/10



i have noo idea why my signature is so lq, oh well

I was never a fan of vertical sigs. But I do like how the eyes are positioned. The colors also compliment one another fairly well.

6/10
Too dirty and small for mah likings :(

1. 6/10 pretty decent however the background shouldn't have been blurred the effects would've been eye poping and text isn't working for me.
2. 5/10 would've been better if liquify want invoved and is lacking effects text is bland and boring

7/10 nice flow
7/10 nice effects i want a tut of that :D

Hmmm... Pretty cool idea. 6/10

Messy effects and not digging the gaussian blur and the text. 2/10

7/10 3/10
The first one is just amazing but the 2nd is much lower

2/10. It all looks low quality, and there is not a focal point.

text could use work, otherwise i like the lighting blending and effects in the 2nd one, nice smudging in the first 7/10 overall :)

Trash complete trash lol jk
1. 7/10 I like the smudge effects but the text is wierd and seems out of place. other than that its awesome.
2. 6/10 Very smooth feeling to it text is a bit eh and there seems to be alot of empty space the left

7/10
I like the fact that the flowers are comming from the hair.
it kinda looks like the hair transforms into flowers :p
You've created pretty good lightning. I don't really like the border

6/10
It looks a bit lq. I like the C4D efects at her shoulder.
the smudging is also pretty nice. The lightning looks a bit weird.
If I were you I would place the lightning source a bit closer to the focal

8/10

The colors, blending, text, and effects are all on point. Great sig.

4/10. I love the colors and the depth but the motion blur kills it for me.

8/10 I like your pull back from the render, I find it hard to smudge :D +1 for talent

You lost points with me cause of the colours >.<

3.5/10.
There's a little too much going on and there's no real depth or light source. The text isn't to good either. I'm not a fan of tiny sigs.

7/10 nice smudge bg but some parts of the render is wrongly smudge IMO anyway KIU

5.5/10, i'm not very sure about this tag