Rate the signature above you.

7/10
Everything is blended really well, not bad depth, but it's missing a light source. :(

6/10
Think the render needs to be blended in more, and the colors in the bg don't match the colors of the render.

8/10
I like this one a lot. Very different style than what I usually see.

7/10
I like the creativeness but I'm not feelin the colors too much.

8/10 now that i actually know what you've done with it

8/10 The effects could be more vibrant
Flow is nice and nice colors going on.

1.)9/10- not feeling the text so much, 2.)9/10- same thing

10/10 that is so amazing, made the sig grungey like the game yet colorful that is really awesome.

8/10,
As stated before, the colours could be a tad more vibrant,
But its really good.

8/10

The effects are nice. Depth is good. The text kills it for me though.

7/10. Pretty cool. :D

To be honest, all I'm seeing is 7-9/10. And there's no way that everyone's sigs are equally impressive. I think we're all being a little too nice to each other. So allow me to be brutally honest without labeling me an asshole :)

If 5/10 is average, anything less being below average, anything higher being above average, I would give the above sig a 6/10.

It's definitely more impressive than what the average newcomer to Photoshop can achieve, but it has a lot of qualities that look noobish to me. Not a bad sig at all though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RunningMan

7/10. Pretty cool. :D

---

For Your Sig,
You just darkened this...
http://www.latoro.com/18140-desktop-...-of-persia.htm
Not very innovative,
As for Monroe's.
A 5/10.

If mine is a 5/10 then I have to give you a 4/10 just because I like mine more :D

But truthfully the reason I give it a lower than average rating is because it's very over constrasted, especially on the hand. The choppy oversharpened effects under his tongue hurt the sig more than compliment it. The text is legible but that's it.

6/10

Not a lot going on here, and the lighting on the left is hurting my eyes.

Not a lot going on? It's a f**kin head getting chopped off! If the lighting is hurting your eyes then I suggest you adjust the brightness on your monitor.

Your sig:

I like the depth you got going on. Although it's all equally clear which is usually a no-no, it's not that bad here. The focal does seemed unfocused to me. Meaning do you want me to stare at the whole render, or just the face, or the red things, etc? The blood spots also seem rather random.

5.5/10

6/10.

Okay then, 7/10 for flow. no text, not a lot of effects and that arm kills it for me

The sig's got a nice depth and color layout, if not a bit too busy, but i like it...

8/10

6/10 too stretchy

Not really digging it, to obvious and dark sides and the text is to faded. Cool idea tho, not easy to make photo manip sig.

5/10

8/10 really cool, those guys scare me though >.<

4 or 5/10

Too much going on. Not diggin the colors, and there are a lot more than one light source in your tag. Not a fan of all the vectors on the left either.

BTW, why the hostility around here? Shit, yall get pissed when someone doesn't like your tag. Chill out, so what if one person doesn't like it? It's one person out of, what? 10's of thousands of GFX'ers. Don't think one person's opinion will way everyone else's opinion.

7.5/10
5/10

4/10

9/10 if made with your own vector shapes

7/10 too much going on

nice smudge, simple but nice :D 8/10

7/10 Would have been better if you did different coloring? The blue highlights stand out from the tag as well, kiu

7/10

The pop out effect on the render is nice :P, but i'm not too sure about your effects. They seem a little off.

3/10. I just don't like it.

7/10
A bit messy with the effects. Lighting is nice though but text could be positioned a bit better.

love the blending but the text killed it for me 7/10
LOVE IT! but text could be placed in a better place IMO 8/10

8/10 its pretty awesome but the C4Ds could flow and blend more,love the colors KIU

1.) 6/10, nice manip, but could have some more effects/depth?
2.) 6/10, liking the colors, but you didn't erase enough to see the whole skyline :/
3.) 7/10, Kind of cool, but everytime I see it, I ask myself, "Why?" Good quality though

5/10.

Text isn't too good. I wish it was bigger.

8/10

6/10
It's not very creative and colorful for the stock.But there's effort.
4/10
You're did right,but made it wrong with not cleaning and blending your effects and adding depth.

4/10.
4/10.
5.5/10. Not digging the text on this one but liking the picture.

love the render and how it attracts your eye in a sec :D but that c4d in his arm is misplaced 6/10

Thanks, but I didn't use any C4Ds. Lol.

7/10. Digging the colors but the blending could be cleaned up a little. Pretty sweet, man!

everything about it is perfect, and the lighting is sick, very nice font, great flow, your one of those people that makes me hate my self -.-

9.5/10 :D