Rate the signature above you.

8.5/10, real nice effects, but that box with the top of the face in it kills it

9/10
I'm lovin' the style, but I personally don't like thick borders.

5.5/10. It just seems a little blurry. Pretty nice flow though. :D

8/10

10/10
are you god?

Very messy but I like those clip masks.

4.5/10

9/10

The blending is great, effects are fantastic and the lighting is awesome.

Bit messy,
Seems random effects all over the place.
Good concept though.
4.5/10.

8/10, would be better if background was a little darker in areas so that you could blend more, keep it up

6/10 - Colors are nice but its just not really my style
5/10 - a bit colorless and the c4d/fractal isnt used as it should be

Keep trying though!

100/10 For the epicness and humor.

First one 7/10,
Things seem a bit random,
Second one 8/10, the colours seem a bit off.
But nice sigs.

7/10 some nice effects on it

3/10
I don't know.

10/10.

7/10

To blurry, but old school ^u^

4,5/10

8.5/10

nc sigs!

1. 5 decent effects lighting is alright. text could use some work.
2. 7 better ligthing is good here.
3. 5 This is just a mess im and chaotic. The text could use work.
Overall you know what youre doing when it comes to lighting.

I like the effects of the first one, the blur seems to be correct as does the lighting, If it was me i would want a tad more colour, but thats just preferance, nice work. :)

Second one i like the effects, the smudging down towards her hair is very nice to me :) Again, i would add more colour, but for these styles of sigs it works well, So nice job on both. :)

4/10 sorry its to small and i dont like the effects at all and the text isnt needed

7/10 i like the smudging and the font of the text fits, but it feels kinda empty and i dont rly like the position of the text.

2/10
7/10

9/10
Really nice overall, the only thing i would have liked to see is if you would make the right, bottom and top left corner black or darker to give it some depth and present the render well. kiu

8/10 really like the smudge effects and text is good just sides could have more smudge :D


new sig hence the re vote

6/10. Can't say I like it a whole lot...

9/10 awesome flow and pretty good depth

6/10
The colors feel a bit weak. But, I love the depth.

7.5/10
Love the effects and smudge, it could have something more though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Joey x

6/10
The colors feel a bit weak. But, I love the depth.

7.5/10
Love the effects and smudge, it could have something more though.

---

9/10 nice colors and effects.

10/10, 'nuff said

6.5/10.

Not bad considering it's simplicity!

4.5/10

I don't really like. It seems you limited yourself to the amount of media you are able to use.
Also, I just don't feel the fractal colors really work.

4.5/5

the font you wrote Joey with just doesn't fit there man.

5/10 the sig has no flow and the effects are covering the focal

8/10
nc use of c4ds,not sure about the lighting..

1st - 7.5/10
2nd - 6.5/10

I already posted why on your other thread ^^.

4/10. The topaz kills it for me.
8/10. The topaz is a little more forgiving here but still over done.

I'm sure you've heard it before, but the use of topaz really eliminates the depth and detail that you should have in your sigs.

5/10

Pretty good just a bit of an over kill with the fractal, Still love it though cause of Spidey :P

5/10 Ehh just a different perspective background and then a render being popped out of the sig. Not really doing it for me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RunningMan

4/10. The topaz kills it for me.
8/10. The topaz is a little more forgiving here but still over done.

I'm sure you've heard it before, but the use of topaz really eliminates the depth and detail that you should have in your sigs.

---

Dude, that doesn't make any sense. I used more topaz in the second one.
The first one was a low strength topaz on 67%.

The second one was left at 100%.

@DR

8.5/10
Lighting needs work and the C4D is a bit too big, but really nice otherwise.

7/10
Not digging the text, major downfall for me.