Rate the signature above you.

6/10 - Love the smudging, but a little bland.
5/10 - Cool text, but the splatters look bad.

9/10. It's text but worked, decent and professional looking.

8/10. I like the how busy it is but not really feeling so much blur.

7/10
I like the colors. Looks to messy tho.

5/10 render is dominating to much of your canvas...

It's just too damn big! :O Seriously though, 7/10 overall. The first one made me giggle, the second one is just ... weird, and the third one is badass. To be honest, I didn't know which one to rate. :P

Solid 6.5
Too small for my tastes

10 for the top lol
7/10 i really like the lighting.

I really like the top one; 9/10.
The bottom one is much too chaotic for my taste, though; 6/10.

5 /10
too much c4d

2nt 1 8.5/10 Kiu Mate, Love the colors the depth the lighting the render the wepon. KIU!

Overall 6.

6/10

8/10

6/10, main focal is too washed out.

http://img854.imageshack.us/img854/9978/dream.jpg

3.5/10

8/10 Kiu.. Nice effects

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Timentia

3.5/10

---

1, you already posted. 2. You're clearly being a douche bag if you give no reason for giving me a 3.5. Also you rated a sig that was terrible 6/10 above lol.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

1, you already posted. 2. You're clearly being a douche bag if you give no reason for giving me a 3.5. Also you rated a sig that was terrible 6/10 above lol.

---

Thread CLEARLY says "Rate the signature above you." not "Give a reason as to why you rated the signature above you like that."
And, so what? If I post once in a thread to rate someone's signature, I'm not allowed to do it once more. (Or did I touch a nerve by not rating it positive?)
And bro, trust me the sig I rated 6/10 would be rated a 10/10 if it were to be put up vs yours.
Game, set, match.

*User above me does not have a signature at the moment, but the one above them gets a... 4/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Timentia

Thread CLEARLY says "Rate the signature above you." not "Give a reason as to why you rated the signature above you like that."
And, so what? If I post once in a thread to rate someone's signature, I'm not allowed to do it once more. (Or did I touch a nerve by not rating it positive?)
And bro, trust me the sig I rated 6/10 would be rated a 10/10 if it were to be put up vs yours.
Game, set, match.

*User above me does not have a signature at the moment, but the one above them gets a... 4/10

---

The point of the thread is to post a sig and rate the one above... Not troll until you find someone you feel like giving a 3/10 to. You clearly have nerd rage and have a problem with me,judging by your reply. Btw adding some fractals to a nice quality anime render doesn't give you the right to talk like a professional. Game,set, match eh? Alright I'm up for that challenge. That person doesnt' even know how to smudge they smudged over top of their render you tool. Going to post both sigs on every gfx forum on the web, just to make you look like the retarded lil troll you are.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

The point of the thread is to post a sig and rate the one above... Not troll until you find someone you feel like giving a 3/10 to. You clearly have nerd rage and have a problem with me,judging by your reply. Btw adding some fractals to a nice quality anime render doesn't give you the right to talk like a professional. Game,set, match eh? Alright I'm up for that challenge. That person doesnt' even know how to smudge they smudged over top of their render you tool. Going to post both sigs on every gfx forum on the web, just to make you look like the retarded lil troll you are.

---

So, I hit a nerve by not liking your 'work'?
By all means I am no where NEAR professional, that does not mean I can not not like someone's art. And, please don't talk about ' that person's' signature if yours is nowhere near half as decent.
And, go ahead you little crybaby, I won't care. But one thing, if you were to get humiliated on every gfx forum on the web, please don't come back crying.. even harder :(

Sad.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

The point of the thread is to post a sig and rate the one above... Not troll until you find someone you feel like giving a 3/10 to. You clearly have nerd rage and have a problem with me,judging by your reply. Btw adding some fractals to a nice quality anime render doesn't give you the right to talk like a professional. Game,set, match eh? Alright I'm up for that challenge. That person doesnt' even know how to smudge they smudged over top of their render you tool. Going to post both sigs on every gfx forum on the web, just to make you look like the retarded lil troll you are.

---

Evry person has his own style, there are no rules how you make your art. if some1 wants to smudge over his render than im sure that it is his taste. dont make some1 low just bcuz he doesnt fullfil the "rules" in your eyes.
and about the low rating, maybe thats not tims style. maybe he shuldnt have rated your tag bcuz of that. just try it again and you will find people that do like your tags :)

I give your tag a 7, i like the colors and love how you have done the smudge :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gaafjeah

Evry person has his own style, there are no rules how you make your art. if some1 wants to smudge over his render than im sure that it is his taste. dont make some1 low just bcuz he doesnt fullfil the "rules" in your eyes.
and about the low rating, maybe thats not tims style. maybe he shuldnt have rated your tag bcuz of that. just try it again and you will find people that do like your tags :)

I give your tag a 7, i like the colors and love how you have done the smudge :)

---

rate mine.

1st 6 :)
2nd 7, love that atmosphere

10/10 for teh first
6.5/10 2nd

7/10 nice effects

2nt one 7/10Kewl

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

http://img854.imageshack.us/img854/9978/dream.jpg

---

Need to stfu Prodigy, this tag is not good, you're the creator so you're going to be bias. The smudging is not at all special or unique, it's monotone, and the text is off to the side which draws your attention completely away from the focal. You post this tag on honest graphics forums and you'll get the same response if not harsher.

I don't, or rather didn't have a problem with you until you commented saying that someones elses tag was terrible that he rated higher than yours. It's his opinion, calm down.

Next poster rate Carsos.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gallagher

Need to stfu Prodigy, this tag is not good, you're the creator so you're going to be bias. The smudging is not at all special or unique, it's monotone, and the text is off to the side which draws your attention completely away from the focal. You post this tag on honest graphics forums and you'll get the same response if not harsher.

I don't, or rather didn't have a problem with you until you commented saying that someones elses tag was terrible that he rated higher than yours. It's his opinion, calm down.

Next poster rate Carsos.

---

Yep, yep and that's all reason to rate something at a terrible level. The text isn't distracting at all, it's blended in the BG properly. Yes the smudging is very trivial, but by no means does it look terrible. I've never on any forum seen anyone give someone that low of a rating, even the WORST tag I've ever seen... Clearly this was done merely to piss me off. I would love to see either you do anything better after 2 weeks of using PS. So anyways I'm not taking anymore shit from this kid, good bye I will find a more constructive forum to get feedback from. Peace.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

Yep, yep and that's all reason to rate something at a terrible level. The text isn't distracting at all, it's blended in the BG properly. Yes the smudging is very trivial, but by no means doesn't it look terrible. I've never on any forum seen anyone give someone that low of a rating, even the WORST tag I've ever seen... Clearly this was done merely to piss me off. So anyways I'm not taking anymore shit from this kid, good bye I will find a more constructive forum to give feedback from. Peace.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

1, you already posted. 2. You're clearly being a douche bag if you give no reason for giving me a 3.5. Also you rated a sig that was terrible 6/10 above lol.

---

LOLLOLLOLLOL
Everybody has their own opinion, and you must be forgetting this is the internet! No ones takes anything serious.

Like I said peace, I'm out. Don't care about your opinion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shiv96

LOLLOLLOLLOL
Everybody has their own opinion, and you must be forgetting this is the internet! No ones takes anything serious.

---

..have you gone through the internet...
my friend
i have started atleast 75 rage threads by saying jokez

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

Yep, yep and that's all reason to rate something at a terrible level. The text isn't distracting at all, it's blended in the BG properly.

---

Not distracting in the sense that it's not blended well, it's distracting in the sense that it's not anywhere near your focal, at all.

Quote:

---

Yes the smudging is very trivial, but by no means does it look terrible.

---

I didn't say that it looks terrible, if he did then that's on him and a separate argument.

Quote:

---

I've never on any forum seen anyone give someone that low of a rating, even the WORST tag I've ever seen... Clearly this was done merely to piss me off.

---

It's his opinion though, if he wants to be particularly tough when it comes to the rating system then he has the right to. Was it to piss you off? Idk, but you shouldn't have brought others tags into it when it was strictly between you two.

Quote:

---

So anyways I'm not taking anymore shit from this kid, good bye I will find a more constructive forum to give feedback from. Peace.

---

Laters, I suppose.

Sad ROFL

6/10
8/10

7/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Prodigy_Gfx

Like I said peace, I'm out. Don't care about your opinion.

---

LMFAOOOOO

First of all You said you dont care about our opions when u just took temia's
Opion more than anyways, then you say you dont care about our opions ur funny.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Carso

LMFAOOOOO

First of all You said you dont care about our opions when u just took temia's
Opion more than anyways, then you say you dont care about our opions ur funny.

---

broski, my name is timentia
and its opinion :p

but were done with that lets get back to rating signatures

You kids playing with my tag? Not nice I should say.

@Tim 9/10. I love it. Just too much of that small textures.