Rate the signature above you.

for the first I would say 6/10 I can't really see much and there is no text
the second 8.5/10 Great light source, fantastic text, nice blending just the bg it is great but maybe a little less blackness it works in the one in you signature but not so much in this one and his body seems to be coming out of ... well i cant really tell
The third same as the second really but im gonna say 8/10 because I don't like the blue creeping in there.

(£10 on my combined score doesn't equal what I gave for the third one)

there is actually text ^^ look harder and the GoW sig, the guy is jumping

um im gunna have to say 4/10 and 4/10, they both need a light source that is bigger they are boht blurry, the render needs some more blurring, and the text draws me in before anything else which prolly shouldnt happen, and on both the width is too long and heigh too small for that width, both renders look cut out pretty cool

^^

Both are very good, although im not a fan of C4D sigs. I would give the top 9/10 and the bottom 8/10. With the nightmare one, the white specs seem a bit to strong and are rather distracting to me, otherwise i would give it a 10/10.

I love that one, 8.6/9 I like the vertical style and the render used. great work.

I love all of your images DE. I hope to be as good as you with Illustrator someday. I give the current randomized sig I'm looking at now [girl with pink eyes, black hair, black clothes and the heart logo in a speak box] a 7.5/10.

hmm i like everything except the text and the lack of color, but good job. 6.5/10

I would give it a 7/10. WOuld be better if it had better text.

Can't really say anything bad about it. But saying that there is nothing brilliant about it. Its a good sig but it isnt that interesting.
7.5/10
btw lol sideboob

Pretty nice could use some more effects

6/10

8/10 - very nice, just don't like the grey bits.

my sig's random, so tell me which one you're rating.