Honestly, and im sorry if this sounds harsh, but i know you mean well by offering this service, but to be honest, like others have said, this is a community of graphics designers. Take this from a fellow anime sig maker, you could really use some of the tuts we have here. Your ichigo tag, the colours dont match at all, the c4d is way too obvious.. halo text? seriously? o.O and scanlines.. Ew. Your sasuke tag, you didnt take the time to blend in the edge of the cutout. Colours dont match, and scanlines again, it just doesnt work for me. The Gaara tag, Gaara doesnt look great on this tag because youve way over shadowed him, its WAY too dark. And again.. scanlines and halo text?
In summary, I commend you for taking this upon yourself to make tags for a wide range of people here, as we have a huge community, however, although you mean well, i would much rather see you develope a style that works with anime tags, with text that fits, If you feel that i have been too harsh with the way i have commented on your tags, please take the time to PM me and if you would like i could help you out a little.
Regards, Fuzer.
04-27-2009, 11:55 AM
Studhorse
Very nicely stated Fuzer.
04-27-2009, 12:02 PM
MarkPancake
All in all, and by no offence intended, your sigs aren't quite up to the same standard as some people around here. And I'm sure you did this out of the good of your heart but this is a graphics forum where WE create sigs and show people the sig for criticism, and have fun with others. If anyone here did need a sig making for them, they clearly are in the wrong place. I'm not sure if you've come from a games forum or something, but it's kinda unneeded...
04-27-2009, 01:56 PM
Comedy_NL
isnt it a good idea to close this topic before a flamewar wil start??