Originally Posted by
Monroe
I don't mean to belittle sig making. And you do have a valid point that making sigs can develop your photoshop skills. All I'm saying is, if anything, sigs should merely be a stepping stone to more comprehensive art pieces. To me, sigs are for beginners to Photoshop. Because they give you a small canvas to work with, and the concept is already laid out for you, no matter what your style is. I think it's safe to say more than 90% if the sigs posted on here consist of a render/stock, a c4d, some smudging, and some effects. Nothing wrong with that. But if you're serious about your artwork, then break out of the boundaries that sigs confine you to.
I don't want to made to look like the villain here. But here is what I see, and this applies even to the guys who make spectacular sigs:
1. You spend hours making a sig.
2. You post it here for criticism.
3. People leave a comment or two.
4. Your thread gets push down the page and disappears into the archive.
5. Your sig is more than likely never seen again.
6. Re-open Photoshop and repeat.
Sigs seem to be what most graphic artists start out making. Then once they get the hang of Photoshop and develop their skills enough, they move on to bigger and better things. So like I said in my previous post, I'm not trying to persuade him from making sigs, I'm just saying that if he wasted a year making them and has only one sig to show for it, then I would leave sigs behind and try his hand at something that can take you to new heights.
If you go on DeviantArt and look at most of the well-known artists, they're not making sigs. Why? Because they got good and left it behind, if they even made them to begin with.
So please, don't look at this as an argument or me starting trouble, I'm just voicing my opinion. And my opinion is that the purpose of making sigs is so that you have something cool looking under your posts. If you want to be a serious digital artist, put your sigs in the garage next to your bicycle with training wheels, and move on to something more serious.