Rate the signature above you.

5/10 Looks really bad imo. Not liking the scan line effect, or the mosaic tile things. Sorry :S
5/10 Nice smuding but once again not liking the scan lines and it looks like you didn't do much to the actual render.

7.5, simple background, but the lighting and effects are really well done. The render blends into them nicely. The effects near the text just seem a little too cluttered and pixely to me though, making it hard to read the word "splint". I wouldn't be able to read it if I didn't look at your username first. It's just that one area of bright turqouise that doesn't blend in with the other colours and the wording.

6/10

9/10 for both. That is if they were your own ideas. As you followed tutorials on both sigs I'll have to say 5/10 :S

9/10
Thats an awesome one!

4/10

6.5/10

5/10

8/10, I like the text.

6/10