Rate the signature above you.

8/10. looks faded to the right..
9/10 Almost perfect! nice!

I know this stock.
not much done with this one.
but effects are really awesome.
8/10
with love :)

hmm
7/10 not your best garis:x

7/10 just doesnt... WOW me?

7/10 nice effects but I don't really like how bright the render is, kinda sudden on the dark background.

7/10 Nice choice of render. Background doesnt really fit it :) The rest is brill

The sig looks good, the text kills it though. The "Shane" seems to bright and stands out to much. It also looks messy because theres a lot of text, maybe get rid of "Making changes" and just put "Shane" there instead.

6/10 because the text messed it up ;)
keep it up,

7/10 text is great, the bg and render blend into each other amazingly, love the colours.

7/10 awesome effects, not keen on the render.
9/10 perfect lighting, it's just very monotone :(

8.5/10. Your best yet. I love the text most of all because it's a risky font to use and doesn't work with many sigs. In tihs case, it works. The smudging is immense. :)