Rate the signature above you.

Even though those aren't made by you, 7/9 for first [animation is too choppy for me] and 7/9 for second 1 [its just funny]

PS: My sig is on random so it changes when it is refreshed, have fun rating them :D

The guitar girl one kicked ass^^ Not to fond of the big white border, butt what the heck:D
8.5/10

^ill give an overall 9/10 for all of your sigs ;)
but the best one so far was the third one..

avril lavigne 6/10

Creed 8,5/10 Text could use some work.

10/10 for spidey:D
Rated your pencil before^^

9.3/10 for all. The 3rd is the niciest ;)

Nice job on the blending:) But IMO the very visible lines on the render ruins a bit=/
But gj^^ 8.5/10^^

8/10 Good job
6,7/10 its not bad but i think u overused the blur lighten thing
9/10 good job

Rating the pencil [already rated spidey]

7.9/9 because it is very unique, and looks like a severely cartoonized pencil :D

your sig is great man, im gonna have to go with 10/10 because you did every bit of it yourself. they really are awesome man. Also your avatar rocks

7/10

Spidey sig = 10/10

1st one i think is pretty cool. Text needs a bit of work though. 8.5/10
2nd one i find something i cant point out that doesnt do it for me. Gj, but 6.5/10

Cloud = 7/10 Seems a little plain around the edges... but otherwise great.
Is that a Photomanip? Haven't seen one of those in a while. 8/10
And... Your last one = 8.9/10 Just shy of a 9.

First one 7,5/10 Work a little on the text
Link 8,7/10 Nice sig text and blnding could use some works other than that good job

its gay

9-9,5/10
8/10

7/10 Isn't interesting to me.
8/10
9.5/10 Its different and i like that a lot.

Latest: Really nice text, and love the sparkly effect, but still obly 8.5/10. Missing something IMO...
Fav: 9/10 love the effect:D Looks like Tom comes out of the C4d(?):D

8/10 nice sig there made have rated the others before:)

Honestly, Amazing. This is one of the best sigs I have ever seen. Only fault, I see, is the text. Just my opinion. Still tho, a 9.5/10.

7.5/9 for the first one. Great quote for a famous statue, but I think the background could have used some touch ups and maybe not so tall.

7.1/9 for the second 1. I am not so big on renders centered in the sig. And it gets too dark on the sides.

I'm not sure which to rate...
I'd give them an overall 8/10 though, their all pretty nice but could use some more detail. :D

Actually really good, exept some of the shadow goes outside the sig:O
But 8.5/10^^

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by silentshadow

Actually really good, exept some of the shadow goes outside the sig:O
But 8.5/10^^

---

Lol yea I didn't want to go over the size limit.

1st one, 6/10- not bad but the render is over blended, text is hard to read and the lighting isn't right IMO.
2nd one, 9/10- very nice photo. :)

9/10 Nice pop artish, vectorish design. The popout is well done and the angle is also well thought of. Nice job.

8/10

9/10

6/10
need to work alot on colours, text, depth, originality :p

7/10 needs font work

8.5/10

1. A little mor blending, colors are nice though, and text needs work, 7.5/10
2. colors match, nice bg but doesnt fit the sprite/render, text needs work, so 6/10

This ones better, I think it would look better a bit bigger though.
8/10

8.5/10
nice vector brushing and great angle ;)
nice work :)

1st: 9/10, but something about the text...
2nd: 9/10:)
Overall very nice work:D

8/10 Nice stock

10/10 I like the focal point

7/10 good colours but a bit small and text is not that great.

8.4/9 for the CATALYST sig. I have always liked how unique it is.

You know I adore you D, and your green-eyed girl is no exception. I won't even put it on a scale because it's too good for one.

7.9/9 Kiera is awesome. And this sig has a few very unique elements in it. Good job!

i'm rating http://www.digitalecstasy.net/sigs/guitarist.png. it's cool beans. think it'd be cool if the guitar wasn't black too, maybe some kinda grey or something. but on the other hand this looks more minimal and that's cool as well. so i dunno. :P


someone rate http://img130.imageshack.us/img130/2530/99ii5.jpg since the thread died too soon.

rofl...
9/10...
bg needs more work...
but text is awesome :)