Rate the signature above you.

dont like the first one much..
too colorful and there are too much stuff over the render..
BG looks randomed too much..
5/10

second is a bit better, but too monotone..
5.5/10

Love the top one. It has awesome flow, and the text is great. 9/10

The bottom one has great colors. Maybe a little too messy in some areas. I don't like the sky text green, when the sky is blue. :P 9/10

8/10 im really liking the fire fx, but i think its oversharpened, but overall a fitting sig KIU m8 :D

HULK 8/10 - nice effects and flow
Kaleidoscope - 6.5/10 Could use some effects to give it more flow, text could be improved too.

7/10 quite a mess there, thogh the effects are going with the flow and love the splatters, tone down the splatter and it did be sex

ahh buu, you've had thos forever.
7/10 top
8/10 bottom love that one.

I'm liking the colours you used and the pen tool skill (If that is what it is) I think the the text adds a touch and shadowing is on. The flow is good, if not perfect. I really can't find anything to critic. 09/10

This sig is mono. The effects make up for it, especially the smoke and I enjoy that. The text is superb. But there is too much emptiness so that needs work on. 06.7/10

6/10
Too monotone and i dont really see what the render is supposed to be .. :p
A dragon ?Monster ?
Not fond of the pentool ..
--
Nice one ,also very monotone ..
7,5/10

6/10
I like the idea of a vector sig, but I think it's missing some effects. Also the composition is a bit off. Just try and add some more things to it.

7.5/10
I like the idea and the composition is good. Again you could've added some more effects here though. Maybe some nice light effects to make the focal really pop out.

6/10 text + too dark on left side and effect on her face, cool effects on the right