The true power of Pro Planet

you know the people that said that kinda of stuff should get flamed this is a great peice and it should be treated as such..db was just one of the first to add a critizism type comment and it picked up off him...you shouldnt just go blaming him alone...it was others as well...

wait never mind...flame his ass this is all he said...i thought it was somthin more constructive as well as critizism....

Quote:

---

no offense dude... but

(yes im really ahrsh)

i really dont like it, it doestn flow - IMO the planets dont look realistic, only the big one and the stars are a tiny bit weird..

title: Hysteria (title of a muse song im listening to)

---

god he did just critizise...man id be pissed too

Illegal didn't critisize as hard as DB since he said he agreed with what others had said, and I took it as he agreed with MetalSkin, who I won't yell at since he gave proper critisicm (which include commenting on what he LIKED), not just telling me that something I've worked on for 3 days is shit. You would get pissed too, believe me. Now who's left.. you? I think you gave better critisicm too, even though some of your points in your earlier post was incorrect (like transparency of the rings). I appreciate that you actually said that this is a great piece. I don't often think that myself, but this time I do. Giving critisicm could help me to improve the pic, but you must do it in a proper way, and I don't think that DB managed to do that since he just said that everything on the pic is bad. I think that's bullshit.

Edit: Oh, you're on my side now. XD Nevermind then.

rofl yes im on your side what db said is bullshit and i am pissed nobody shoulda said that about this peice...its one of your best peices and if u keep at it it'll just get better, if u have time durin the summer try a version 2 maybe? to see where your at then compared to now...maybe db will learn some respect...he should actually C&c not just Critizise..db said it doesnt flow...as you stated you didnt want it to flow it was just a tryout to see what you could do with the tut...in the end you agreed the top left planet didnt work as well as the others but in the texture and other stuff area its great tho in proportion its a little off because its near to the larger planet...the big planet has some nice features but due to your shading effect you pulled off quite nicly im might add doesnt show all those features to their full extent. db should have actually commented...not just flame

Thank you for the comment. :)

And I reckon any of you guys have noticed the little thingy in the lower right corner. >;]

I've already commented this one... But not here xD

I love it! Some of you may not have noticed, but there are actually cities on the planet that looks really awesome!! The big planet is the best one, and the perspective looks kinda odd on the planet above it, but it's ok... You can't see all the sources of light, so I dunno if it's realistic or not :P

The Death Star is another funny thing to input. I think it's awesome ;P

BTW: I understand it's not perfect, but ur friggin 16 yrs old, man!! xD

I like how every planet has a moon. I'm just stunned. You are very talented.

DragonsRage: Thank you. :) This is just my second space scene, so it's not perfect, but I will keep getting better and better untill I'm as good as Alyn on DA. ;) I am for the moment learning how to make nebulas, and I will of course practice on everything, study real space, and so on.
You will definately see more space scenes, I have really found my thing in digital art.

Chill OUT guys. People can have their own opinions - and I dont want to see people bashing him for it.

Jesus christ chill out guys. And set an example Twan.

Quote:

---

Originally posted by Rabieshund@May 27 2005, 05:13 AM
Yes, you are trying to help, I appreciate that, but telling me that you totally dislike the pic isn't really helping. It just makes me feel bad at what I'm doing, which I don't think I am. I mean, no positive stuff at ALL? Come on, that's just ridiculous. Deep Blue really doesn't know how to critisize properly, he forgot that this pic isn't just some thing made in paint. No one of you have commented on that I put really much work into it, which I'm kinda proud of, either.

[snapback]56159[/snapback]

---

i do know how to criticise properly however i didnt state anything good - im sorry for that but really, ya dont have to go and get annoyed

IMO i think the front planet looks kinda good, but the others look unrealistic and out of place- especially the distant ones, before i was just stating my opinion, and if you cant accept that i dont think its that good then thats your problem. i do like some of it, just when i look at it.. it doesnt look to me interesting and eyecatching, i understadn how you put 3 days work in - those planets take ages, i know (just ive never shown mine cause they rele crummy) i just dont think it flows too good

oh and when you said that you doubt no one could do it... thats not tru

Quote:

---

Originally posted by Twan@May 26 2005, 10:27 PM
How can you judge a planet?* Tell me.* That's whatgot me to say that.* There is no "realistic" planet.* A planet could be a box for all we know in some areas.

[snapback]55995[/snapback]

---

lets not go that far ey :P

the piec looks absolutely stunning! I've always been a fan of space panorama's, but this makes me wanna get better at it :PI'll be sure to check out your tut on planets...
All I can say abt it is that it looks really good, except for a minor glitch in shadow/lighting...
I'm not talking abt the rings, cuz honestly, if the light were coming from the centre of the oval galaxy, the rings and planets look well lighted.
Only problem is, that that wouldn't be their primary lightsource, as it would be too far away. A closer sun would provide the light. You'd have to add a sun in a diffenrent location or so... but that's really bickering over nothing, cuz prolly no-one will really notice...
It's a great job man!