6/10
9/10
It's pretty unique i really like it
Printable View
6/10
9/10
It's pretty unique i really like it
4/10 cant see whats the focal point.
5/10 the bg and text both need work and your render is blurred:)
9/10, makes me drool all over
7/10, don't like the circly thing
oh.. I like the look, but the border looks strange to me and car need to move up.... also need work with text and those pattern lines really district me... so:
8/10 is the whole look -1 for bad border; -0,5 for text; -1 for lines and -1 becouse details with can and bg needed so...
4,5/10 I think its a fair result...
my text always sucks....
For Erik:
Background i think fits the car, colours are really nice, but make your border a bit thinner, and i think it will look good. Remove the scanlines fomr the whole sig, and cut the white outline on the text, and lower the opacity on the text.
5/10
9/10
simply luv it
good job
lol i already rated those signatures blackhawk =P but ill do it again (BTW NSR on the second one, there is no focal, its an abstract no render etc) (on the first one i know i messed up, so yeah) blackhawk 6.9/10 8/10
6/10
8/10
i like the colors in the 2nd one
6.8/10, too much ripple IMO, and all the stuff is going in one direction, and up towards the eear its blended too much, its okay splatttering, looks like lava, i cant do it, at least with this shitty photoshop i got
8/10
8/10
5/10
7,5/10
Ps i dont like your text on both of them that needs work
9/10
7.5/10 the lighting and the c4ds look kinda out of place.. should be more on the right. Like the text.
8/10
7/10
1- very nice looking tag, great blended but i miss something
2- the bubbles looks cool but its still feels like its missing something.
Generally both is good tags
i dont like it...
i dont see text... maybe some work on bg but thats all... and in my opinion render dont fit in bg... 2/10
5/10
6/10
maybe comments?
8/10, love the skater sig, its nice abstract cool and the um garis "unrateble" uhm 3/10 cuz u spelt unratable wrong =P and its too much repition in both ur sigs with the png background i guess, text is pretty cool tho
dunno how to rate yours..
maybe 8/10 ;)
but I sak to not RATE Garis tag... I wish you wont rate it... I thought that RATE nagative will be UNRATE and I will make it like adjective so +BLE... and,... But how to write it correct? I will correct... ;) but please dont rate that...
8.3/10 im liking the skater sig more each time
*Please rate these instead i dont wanna change my current sigs*
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z...lthingcopy.png
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z...4byrinthv2.png
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z.../darkelfv2.png
for the first I would say 6/10 I can't really see much and there is no text
the second 8.5/10 Great light source, fantastic text, nice blending just the bg it is great but maybe a little less blackness it works in the one in you signature but not so much in this one and his body seems to be coming out of ... well i cant really tell
The third same as the second really but im gonna say 8/10 because I don't like the blue creeping in there.
(£10 on my combined score doesn't equal what I gave for the third one)
there is actually text ^^ look harder and the GoW sig, the guy is jumping
um im gunna have to say 4/10 and 4/10, they both need a light source that is bigger they are boht blurry, the render needs some more blurring, and the text draws me in before anything else which prolly shouldnt happen, and on both the width is too long and heigh too small for that width, both renders look cut out pretty cool
^^
Both are very good, although im not a fan of C4D sigs. I would give the top 9/10 and the bottom 8/10. With the nightmare one, the white specs seem a bit to strong and are rather distracting to me, otherwise i would give it a 10/10.
I love that one, 8.6/9 I like the vertical style and the render used. great work.
I love all of your images DE. I hope to be as good as you with Illustrator someday. I give the current randomized sig I'm looking at now [girl with pink eyes, black hair, black clothes and the heart logo in a speak box] a 7.5/10.
hmm i like everything except the text and the lack of color, but good job. 6.5/10
I would give it a 7/10. WOuld be better if it had better text.
Can't really say anything bad about it. But saying that there is nothing brilliant about it. Its a good sig but it isnt that interesting.
7.5/10
btw lol sideboob
Pretty nice could use some more effects
6/10
8/10 - very nice, just don't like the grey bits.
my sig's random, so tell me which one you're rating.
THE MASTERS SWORD
Very nice love the detail on the vector sword..!!
8/10;)
I love everything about it. I love the colors and i love the composition. 9/10
mmm this is hard, cuz it isnt all that interesting but its a relatively nice sig... id give it maybe a 7/10? or so its cool and it blends nice, mightve been cool if you stuck the text on the flag pole ^^ it could also use some lighting and im not exactly a fan of the colors ^^
rate these instead please, ive gotten lots of ratings on the other ones
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z...ictioncopy.png
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z...lthingcopy.png
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z...4byrinthv2.png
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z.../darkelfv2.png
(Yes I know they all are about the same color, it was a new style thing i was trying out)
i'm rating the first one.
7/10 - pretty nice, probably your best. text needs work, could be a little sharper, and i don't like how some of the effects are going into his face. colors are good. the top border doesn't extend far enough to the right. and it's a png :(
again, random sig, let me know which one you're rating.
the fire emblem one i dont like the right side of it at all like after the um B on the "Emblem" part, the lighting is pretty nice but maybe too much splattering and stuff, also its too wide for the size of the render i think, not as good as the moon godess definetely...7/10
8.5/10. blending could be a littttle better.
9/10. Very soft. Simple and complicated at the same time. I like it. text needs improvement.
I like the first one.. I like left side, but for some reason, that I dont know I give you 7,5/10
and for second one i give 6,5/10 becouse I dont the meaning of the sig, dont know that have to mean this playlist... so...
i like the contrast you used with the red fingernails but the sig in all isn't that interesting to me. Good composition though so i'll give it a nice 7/10 :)
oh... thanks.. you see no one was commented this one I have.. so I dont know minuses in my work. Ignored.....
and about yours...
I like it..
first one. imo 420 can be smaller and it will be better if the loop of g be.. maybe add 1px white stroke to gibson... something missing to me.. hmm... 6,5/10
and second?.. i like it more but some details need in bg and need some work with text... so IN MY OPINION 7,5/10 ;)
Who is that girl in your sig? I give it an 7.6/10 because I like the eyes, skin tone and blur effect. But the candy cane line on the right looks kind of awkward though.
