Rate the signature above you.

7/10 good job here.

8/10 Fantastic Lighting.
9/10 Love it.

Eagle: Superb job. Så well blended and very nice colors and effects. 8.5
Bubbles: Almost perfect. Although something, i dont know what, is missing. But one of my favourite sigs of all time. 9.5/10

I know that I commented you guitar a lot, but I just love it more and more :D
10/10 :) really great job on that :) :)

If you don't see mine http://img70.imageshack.us/img70/6905/sig295jo9.jpg

Pretty cool, although, a lot of the things seem randomly placed, and take away from the overall effect.
7/10

no idea who the guy on it is supposed to be, but i like the text, and the claw things on the left, but i think the spirals on the right could be placed a little better. 7.5/10

idk...i ont want to give a low rating, but im not exactly sure it deserves a fairly good rating...
anyway, you need better effects (and no, just becuz theres animation does not mean it has good effects), text, depth, lighting, flow...basically everything needs work. look at some tuts(especially daemon's!)

whats my rating though?? and umm i like ur fav alot, i like the sand effect 9.5/10

your newest i give a 7/10, because its vertical, and that makes it seem way to small

EDIT: ty silent shadow,,, i didnt really expect it to be good, cuz i just started, but now i know what to work on!:D

i agree with s0ggy...
3.5/10 for me, sorry, but looks like you didnæt make an effort on the bg, just smashed a render onto it, added the "blood" and text needs lot of work. AND i don't like animation like that, so...

I like the sig, very simple, and it has a nice glow, but the right side seems a bit off. The color looks a bit over-sharpened, but not too badly. I give it an 8/10, good job, nice and simple =)

mm. Nice border, good effects... :)
7,5/10

6.5/10
nice. a few strokes at the top right corner of the border look weird.
The borders would look better if they were square as well.

mmm. thanks :)

9,5/10

and

9,5/10

those two are kinda similar to each other, same bgs nad colors

neato concept, and execution is decent. but i would like to see some effects in the sig itself, rather than just a fancy border =D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by s0ggywaffls

neato concept, and execution is decent. but i would like to see some effects in the sig itself, rather than just a fancy border =D

---

so rate???

i would give it 8/10 it nice sig and kewl concept but a little more effects would be nice. make her legs and soks fading away too like the stomach

baby moon 10/10 great effects and very well blended.

the darkness 10/10 (i would love to see a tut on this one it's great):)

ill give it a 8.5/10
seems a little too plain

6.5/10 theres not much too it, and idk if its just me but i dont like how the guy on the left looks... and theres no backround is there?

EDIT; ty fyasko, yeh, i tried to make it as red as i could, and i was thinkin of putting some blood spater on there but i didnt want to, cuz it didnt go w/ the background.. and the lettering thing i got from a tut in here...

5/10

The render is sick, but the background is so simple it makes it look bad. The pink coloring doesn't really flow, I feel like it should be red, blood red, if you will. The random grey spot? I'm not sure. And the "Show No Mercy" text should definitely be consistent coloring, you can hardly read the beginning letters to each word.

Needs Improvement. :|

4-5/10
Not bad pen tool but it looks boring, nothing is going on at all.

Baby Moon: Amazingly well blended, great use of colours and lighting - 10/10!

The Darkness: Great overall feel, but I can't help thinking the render is blended a bit too much. However, I like the text and how you worked it into the background - 8/10.

I like it^^
It has a great flow IMO
Good text, only work a bit on his eyes:)
8/10

very well blended and text goes well. not too sure about the colours though seem too bright.

First one:

Too much text in my opinion, also that color too hard for me...
6/10

Secnd one:

More simplier, more nicer to me :) But you can work on details in BG. :) 7/10

wow damn, i have not been on in like 4 months... umm but im gunna say.... like wow.... umm 9.2/10? i love the outside work on this, its really amazing.

Oh.. thanks... :)

And..

Your wokrs also amazing to me.. They look so cool for me... :) nice job on those ones :)

9/10 for both :)

Hmmm the first one, I love the outside work im not gunna lie =P, although u kinda rubbed away her tits...=PP, its got a really really really nice depth perception to it, and the abstract work outside of it is really cool.

also, the little guy is SWEET =PPPPP you should add some splatters to him tho

9.1/10= Number 1

its really simplistic but awesome as it is! (even if it isnt the most graphically pleasing to the eye or interesting) 10/10!!= number 2

wow..so many.
Well, I like the abstract one. It's very...experiemntal and unique. I also like the one right below it, but it can use a little bit of more light on the side. I like all of it.
I say 9/10
:D
awesome sigs

hmmm.. dunno what to say...

7/10 for both

the first one is very odd i must say... but i like it... hmm 7 for the 1st, and 6 for the 2nd, because there should be more to him...

6/10 for that sig tain.
the text dont appeal to me, so as with the blurred bg.

These sigs are so nice to me ;)
I give 8 or 9 / 10 to the first one. right side empty to me a little :( anyway good job :)

and 8 or 9 / 10 to second one ;) everything looks nice and clean, but right side kinda boring, only smudged.. :) anyway nice job ;D

1st 1 seems kinda empty, not much goin on it it
7/10

i really like the 2nd 1 tho
its very creative an simple
9/10:D

1=8.7/10
2=8.3/10

1st is nice i just dont exactly like the style to it, and the graphics arent as interesing as they could be, needs some more contrasting and darker lines i think, perhaps more opacity in some of the lines and different shades and shadows

2nd is also pretty cool, i like the style to it, its just not as...interesting as it could be? could use some random lines something....and it has 2 light sources... it wouldve been cool to have made the explosion thingy the light sources along with the eyes of course, and then having everything else based on that. its still a sick sig tho

1st is prty chaotic, colors are prty whacked, but not bad. 6/10
second i LOVE!!! way better than i could hope to do. great job, 8/10
last, effects and colors are prty bland but its okay. 5.5/10

7/10
I really like the flow of it and the color choices are great also

5/10
Text is bad
Nothing really good to look at

love the car great flow colours ect 9/10
the second one is good but a bit plain, i don't like the text either 7/10

Nick text is awesome. Infrno text not so awesome. 8.5/10
Cool looking sig, a bit empty though. 8/10

1st: cool text love the flow to it, not much to it? still a good sig for what it is...although cant really rate it, not your typical signature...but for what kind it is....ill give it a 8.7/10

2nd: pretty cool, not my kind of stil nice blending nice effects all that kind of funk, just not my style man still a 7/10 tho