Rate the signature above you.

7/10 i like the way you used c4ds

9/10 love abstract art :)

8/10 i like it how you smudged a bit then placed the same renders just in a differen't spots to make it look like he/she(can;t tell :P) is moving

hmmm

7/10

cool bg, render doesnt fit with it and its not blended enuf... plus u have 2 light sources...text aint great

but its still a cool looking design

also... ...i dont have smudge on my version of fotoshop...whatever you thought that was...i dont have it lol...i guess i got lucky.

5/10 lookds to random
8/10 good flow and colors
6/10 kind of plain imo

8/10 - nice flow and depth

6/10 - i think this one looks too flat

6/10 interesting but it's a bit bland.

I cant really tell what is going on. Not blended at all as i can see it. Bg looks cool.
6/10

Heh... Maybe I won't rate your first :D
Second... :) I am not the fan of this BG color, but Sig is very nice :) let me think... :D 8 or 9 /10

8.9/10 o first:D
9.8/10 on last:D so f'ing cool:D

first one is...interesting...what is it? 3.5/10

2nd is just text so i wont comment.

3rd is not bad, but its lacking in deth and lighting. 3.5/10

oh and just so everyone knows my rates are based on the rank system, so a 5/10 would be around mod. so a3.5/10 is like high novice.

8/10 Nice light sorce on that.

9/10 Nice blending with the render .

Dont like the text, render is too little blended. Anyways a good sig. 7.5/10

BTW: My first is a 35 px white soft edge brush with wind, ripple and some gradient layers:P Easy, but i like it:)

9/10 on the sig, I like the blending, effects and lighting

uhm...6.8/10 (using soggywaffles' rank system thing) its cool and the effects are pretty cool, but its rather bland, and text needs work, border kinda bugs me and size, its too wide...its mainly the text tho... nice c4d special effects rendering tho...at least thats what it looks like

1st one i give it 10/10 no flaws wat so ever
2nd one i give it 8/10 i hve no idea wat the Focal is dude
3rd one i give it 8.5/10 the stroke around the render must be GONE. the effects on the left side shud be blended more into the sig. the right side is so plain. I like the idea tho and the text is awesome. light source is ok i guess..but this render makes it hard for a ligh source seein how both sides have shadows

9/10 Beautiful effects and text
7/10 Bad text placement
8/10 good effects, but text not to great (red text)

8/10 for maybe good idea of "water" :D
8/10 nice one. Dont have to say anymore.

Like The 3d Effect Really Nice 9/10

3,5-4/10 Im not a fan of this:) the colors are to monotone, the bg is some abstract brushing if i aint wrong? the scanlines dont help :)

Like always, I cant give you lower than 10/10 :)

7.5/10, I love the popouts, but not the stock :(
8/10 Simple and lively, I like it :D

Yo broha sisha

these are some pretty sickness work yo

I like the depth on the 1st one but sizing and some other factors are a tad weird for me.

2nd one

i like the right side, its interesting, after the left side of her nose it gets...dirty and not good for me

like....6.7/10 on the 1st one

6/10 on the second

(scalings based off of old rates)

all 7/10. :)

7-8/10 for both :)

I really like your signatures, great depth and blending..
I dont rly like that C4d or whatever it is at the left bottom of the Logan-sig.
7/10 Logan
8/10 "spiderman?" :P

Btw, I know mine reeeally lack in depth but it always pops up in my mind, like, 1h after it's done >.>

oh.. really nice with firts one.. :)
I like it very much.. :)
9/10

and what the hell heppened to second one... ?
6/10

I see you got a guitar now, eh? :P
I has an new, too x)

8/10 for the guitar, same as your spidey :P

Which one was my 9/10 again? that Gorillaz or the "Insane"? :P

Your gorillaz...
But now I think I gave you too much :D
Anyway... 9 or 8 / 10is very high rate :) Gj..
And maybe you can say why you gave me 8/10. Why not 10/10? :D

And your wolf also really nice..
Kinda monotonic colors,
But I like the text very much,
and nice gaussin bluring on the right side,
But IMO its too much :)
Maybe too little of details, really not much of them..
Anyway very nice :)
8/10

Noobified :P
10/10
a little too visible c4d's (IMO) -1
text, slanted and not very blending -1

Otherwise i love it (srsly :P)

By the way: I am changin ur spidey, loving it more n' more :P
9.5/10, love that f*ck't up circle :> (-0.5 cause of the pixelsharpenstuff at the left side, nawt mie stile :P)

Hehe i like how ppl are giving tens and 9's like it was easy to recieve,

remember 10/10 most be the perfect sig for you since its the higest rate :) haha

Well the wolf one looks really nice and great depth 7,5/10 Great job
The gorillas look good but the text and light (mostly the light, wich is very big) ill give it 5-6/10

I love the baby moon, 10/10 :>

The darkness.. about 6/10, most of it is really great.. everyone says you shouldn't concentrate on the render when you rate anything, I can't here.. I don't really like that render.. :l

Love them both.

first one has awesome depth and contrast. Great text as well. 9/10

Like the background and grunge look of this one. 7.5/10

I am going to go with ~8.2/9

The colors [or lack there of] really works well, and the effects are nice.

i like the randomization :D
8/10

1st one, hmm.. about 8/10 dno why, just kinda like it :P

2nd one.. hmmm. not my style.. about 5/10 ..soz, someone else may like it :P
again.. not my style..

wolf one 9/10 very well blended and has great lighting.
gorrilaz 8/10 well blended ect, but a little to much light on left hand side.

We should get this thread movin again.

Latest: 7/10 - The duplicate on the left is very distracting, and the text is distracting as well. However the BG is very good, nice and intense. It could use more depth however.

Greatest: 7ish/10 - The bg is very flat looking. It needs a lot more depth or something. The blending is great. The text needs some work as it is very distracting. I would try to stick with defaults, like you did in your latest sig. It worked out pretty well. COlors are nice.

Keep going at it. I see significant improvements in your latest sig.

pretty cool

7/10

I like the first one :) I would use other gradient map, i am not the fan of colors like those, but anyway it looks nice, ;) 7,5/10

I am not the fan of second one. nice effects here. the text not bad too.. but i dont like the BG... 5,5/10

7/10, i like those effects you used on it
6/10 good, but the colors dont really go :\

Thanks :)
You too really need work on those ones... :)

Maybe I give 5,5/10 for both :)