Rate the signature above you.

8/10
First one: I love mw2 so this makes it better xD But seriously, i really like the flow and the render is nice. Only couple thing i would say is: i dont really like text + more gradient map. But its simple and clean! GJ

7/10
Second one: Same as first one ( about the text and gradient map). About the background, i like the floral brush and heart, fits well with the render, but the thing behind it... not too sure!

Overall 7.5/10 good job!

Nice, the first one looks pretty strong. Mayb a bit overlightened Mmh.. 8/10
I dont know why, but the second doesnt look good in my opinion.. I think its that the smudge is too much.. But the text is really awesome :D 7/10

6/10: The text needs work and there's too much negative space on the left.

7/10 nice render and nice c4d added with colors but looks quite simple

Love it:)
Like the colors and the gold effects
The contrast is great too;)
9/10

Hmmm which one should I rate?

I prefer the top one. I am not a great fan of C4D's but both are good,
The only thing I can suggerst is learning to blend your text a bit more

The amount of animation kind of makes it a little busy, but it's a good animation. The tag itself (discounting animation, etc.) is kind of slap and go, which is okay for the tag due to what it's supposed to be for. All in all, it's a good tag, just maybe not so much animation next time.

5.5/10

lol. too many too rate.

#1 - ill give it a 7/10. some parts are over too sharpened . And make the
text stand out a bit more. BUt not taking the focus on focal.

#2 - ill give it a 8/10. the H on the halo is being covered.
nyc flow imo.

#3 - ill give it a 9/10. i like the contrast on illidan's dagger. And some nice smudging there.

I see on most of your sigs it has some negative space in the bottom. I like it:D.
KIU man.

9/10 cool :)

8/10 not liking the background :)

9/10 Amazing effects on the guitar, love how it pops out from everything else and is complemented with the dull color around it.

7/10 Very simple but I love the expression on their faces. Mountain Kids meet the midnight city