Everybody has their own way of making sigs, I personally don't think theres a right or wrong way of doing it. It should be whatever way makes the individual happy not what makes everyone else happy.
If you guys want to debate this topic further then go start a topic in the debate forum. This is the battle forum, so battle or shut up.
04-20-2006, 08:19 PM
aefx
in before closing :D
also sobek gmvizzle
04-20-2006, 08:32 PM
Sui Generis
8-3, sobek gets the win. congrats. gl next time anarchy.
04-21-2006, 10:13 PM
photekUG
no brushes, its called soemthing called c4d my friend, owned yet again,
04-21-2006, 11:46 PM
Wiseson
YEAH ITS OPEN!!! Sobek gmv without a doubt. Why you might ask? Well i love the colors i like the effect, even though i would sharpen it alittle to me its more to look at and he seems to have put more time into it. Anarachy's sig just looks like a render brushed with alot of dled brushes, colored, then brightness/contrast....and his second sig....wtf that shit is ugly as hell imo.
04-21-2006, 11:50 PM
Sandman
if this was still going no way on the planet id vote for sobeks, sobeks sig is an eyesoar anarchys is pleasant and flows nicley
and most of all actually looks good looks like a sig and who cares if a sig is original, original basically means wierd and if its original and ugly why the **** would one want? nice job anarchy
04-21-2006, 11:52 PM
Sui Generis
fine.. we'll leave this open until someone reaches 10
sobek- 9
anarchy-4
04-21-2006, 11:56 PM
Sandman
also i bet if anarchy had as many post as sobeks votes would be scattered around a little bit more in my opinion. Sobeks is more original but doesn't look good even if he didn't use brushes or anything brushes are meant to be used and can turn up some cool pieces of work. Anarchys is less original the color choice is nice and is almost always pleasant on everyones eyes especially mine when i look at sobeks i cringe, its just not a good sig by sobek he can do better -peace-
also my dad is an artist he paints paintings and went to art school i know this doesn't have much to do with digital art but i show him your guys sigs on here and just about everyones sig on here he points out mistakes that all you guys make which are pretty bad that most true paid graphics designers would frown upon
04-21-2006, 11:56 PM
Sobek
Ahhh, i was speaking to Elektrik yesterday, and he said the only reason he voted for Anarchy was because we had beef. So it would really be 10-3.