Printable View
9/10 I don't like giving perfect scores, but I think the energy round the tree is cool. The off shoot looks a bit out of place in comparison to the rest of the sig.
I made this for a friend about 2 weeks ago:
http://i129.photobucket.com/albums/p...p_Dead_Sig.png
So could the next person please rate this, and my current Sig as well.
Thanks :)
7/10 The light on the right of him is cool.
7/10 Original idea!
8/10 Depth is nice in this one, so is the lighting though I think it could use a bit of work on the left. Also, I can't read the text on the bottom easily, and I think the "On the strengths of your Martyr" is unnecessary.
extinction 7/10 i see some nice effects. nice stuff
head of the storm...7/10 as well it looks like a bunch of water splashing over the render. no worries cuz i tink it looks cool:p
Top one, 8/10 great lighting effect from center but could do with something on the top left hand corner. c4d or something with low opacity :P
http://www.freeimagehosting.net/uploads/289a7c9d07.png
8/10 nice stuff
5/10 not really digged in.
hehe
i always get stuck with you ^_^
well still 7/10
and 8.5/10
I'll give it a 7, I love the concept but parts of the tree look a little to sharpened.
hmm
0/10 for stealing my stock
8/10 for the sig
^_^
8.5/10
8,5/10
7/10
8/10 - Love the blending and the text is authentic Deathnote text. :D
6/10 - A little empty but again great blending and awesome text. :D
6/10 need more blending imo
7/10 great idea dig it to the max
7/10 like it very different to the usal rectangle sigs.
5/10 just a bit cluttered with c4d's
actually there was only 1 c4d usage done in the last sig it's all brushes ;) and the c4d usage was on the top left side
on topic: 5/10
5/10 not really diggin the blending overcontrasted
ah kk ur second didnt show up was only the ichi one but still a bit cluttered imo
7/10 i like the way u have done ken in ur second sig looks very nice
hmm
4/10
3/10
8/10 nice job :D
Would do with abit of sharpening, looks blurred to the right.
7/10 though.
7.2/10 looks pretty cool
5.5/10 don't like this one:S
hmm, sorry, but i don't like it :/ 4/10
post u gotta rate it as well.
so i'll double rate.
flatty: 7/10 its pretty nice. is that samus?
post: 7/10 looking nice. sorta oversharpened...but nice.
Ups forget that :D
Yours:
6/10 i like some parts of it
7/10 needs a sharpen imo, but nice :)
8.5/10 I think the render placement makes the sig very dramatic. I'm not a fan of the dark sides and oversharpened. I take that dark side comment back. it addes to the dramatization
hmm
3/10
4/10
7/10 - I like the lines but the sides it's a bit empty. The effect of the lightning is awesome though. :D
7/10
6.5/10
ur okami one is real nice.
7/10. Bit grainy and the bottom is rather off. Nice imagery though.
6/10
lines in the right dont fit at all imo.
colors are decent.
bg is empty.
tet needs work
idk garis, your stuff is darn near perfect :p
8.7/10 something seems a tiny bit off but it's so perfect i can't tell what
9/10 just dayumm
7/10 The colors dont flow all that well
6/10 Not much going on, on the left side
6/10 bit monotone maybe work on the text (also floating head IMO :S)
7.5/10 Like the manip but doesnt look like you have done much else maybe change text positions :D
8 too dark in some areas
8.5 good source of lighting and meaningful also
upper: 7/10 looks pretty cool
lowest: 6/10 looks squished and don't like the effects
hmm 7/10
I gave you a 9-10 last time, and it hasn't changes. Still is a nice sig!
Ptka-> I love that Okami sig that you have made. It looks amazing :D
Could someone rate this one please:
http://i280.photobucket.com/albums/k...PainterSig.png
that sig with girl is...
I dont know.
I dont like it much.
there is no blending, no flow, text need work. 5/10
now your current.
awesome. 7/10.
I will give you 8/10 if you remove those things in the side :p
The davidfarrel one: nice sig, i like the tekst and effects. 7½/10
Spiderman: Absolutely awesome 8/10 nice job :)
hmm
5/10, horrible text, and just looks bad in quality
8/10, good lighting, nice color choices, good flow, bad text
