Rate the signature above you.

bradby didn't rate so i'l do it 2 times:)
PTKA
upper: 7.5/10
lowest: 5.5/10

Bradby
Superman sig: 6/10
Hulk : 6/10

8/10 i love the text, concept and style nut i feel i need more depth and deeper colours like abit of red :S

8.5/10

7/10

hmm
8/10
6/10

I Like the concept of yours John, 7.8/10


http://i381.photobucket.com/albums/o...UG/Ironamn.jpg

ahh. okey. a superman. :D
need to erase some efects over the render.
superman dont fit in the BG becouse of colors.
6/10

8.5/10
9/10
good stuff garis

8/10

8/10

9/10

7/10

Text is gross. Doesn't really match Tupac.

8.2/10

upper = 9/10 so loving that one;)
lowest: 6/10 not my kinda sig;)

7/10 bit plain on the sides

F

7.5/10. Colors and render aren't my style. looks good though.

7/10 hmm looks like a Big C4D not rly my style but still nicley placed :)

they both looks nice ;]
8/10 for the first. left side is too dark for the right side.
or right side is too bright for the left side.

7/10 just too dark. but I like text a lot :)

9/10 =]

6/10

Nice background but it doesn't really go with the render.

7/10 not much to say about it:p

9/10 love it

uuuh there's like 4/5 sigs there so on average i'd say 8/10 :]

I love it the lightin n shadows r great 9/10

hmm
5/10
4/10

I dont like it personally 4/10

Hmmmm...
This is a Noodle-Scratcher Buuuuuuuuuuuuuuut.
7.8/10 for the top one.
6/10 for the bottom.

Not really much.

7.5/10

Hmmm, I'd have to give it a 6/10 Without the render, But Nice work :) Keep it up :)

yhey post #1993, thats when i was born ^_^

6/10, the background looks nice but the text and render doesn't really fit.

it could be more darker.
need some contrast.
but effects are great. ;]
7,8/10

Total crap, both of them. 0.00000000000001/10 :p

Haha.

Top is awesome 9/10
Bottom 8/10

5/10

its wierd...i donno wat i'm looking at
but that's ok...cuz its whacked out like u ap:p

7/10 I Like the way you used dr. Dre and the Splatter Brush.




http://i381.photobucket.com/albums/o...UG/Illidan.jpg

I'm not a fan sorry the focal is dim and the text is a bit off... 6/10

first-9/10 sometimes simplicity is the best.
second-6.5-not diggin it

7/10 like your idea but maybe the outcome could of been pulled out better

5/10 i just dont like wat you have done to him :S IMO it just looks horriblw :S and the border is rubbish to :D

I said once, I just dont like your first much. 6,5/10
second one looks really great. I like it. A bit overblured, text is great ;]
8/10

i like the first one, its very nice. 7/10
2nd one is nice too...sry i cant rly think of any critique, they both look good =]
7/10

7.5/10
8.5/10
nice work sogs:D

liking it 8/10, you seem to have that one for ages