Rate the signature above you.

8/10
6/10
good job :)

4/10

Top - 7.5/10
Bottom - 8.5/10

10/10 cuz ur apathy:p

i'm not a big fan of vertical sigs.
and i think you could add some more work on your text
7,5/10

Nice but hate your text, looks extremely pixelated in my opinion.
8/10

7.5/10
8/10

=]

8/10... i like.
I'm new to GFX, so everything here looks awesome...:P

8/10

Blendings good, but might use a lil bit more, im not sure tho lol. And since ive learned a lil bit about txt today, the text stands out a bit too much, and its a lil empty, but it looks nice, which is what really counts :D

I miss something on the first. 6/10
secind one is better imo.
nice blending/ 6,5/10

8/10

7/10

6/10

2nd 1 looks rlly nice its awsome, but te plain white background bothers me 8.5/10, u shuld make a tut

6/10 - good effects, little chaotic and needs a color scheme, text is lacking but not bad
10/10 - ANIME FTW~! :) lol

Oh and there is a tut for my second sig, well, its for a sig in the exact same style. Search "Miril's Ghost Recon" in tuts section and it'll come up.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Miril

6/10 - good effects, little chaotic and needs a color scheme, text is lacking but not bad
10/10 - ANIME FTW~! :) lol

Oh and there is a tut for my second sig, well, its for a sig in the exact same style. Search "Miril's Ghost Recon" in tuts section and it'll come up.

---

1st sig not sure doesnt apeal to me much its good i'd say 8/10 and the second 1 was a premade not mine lol ANIME FTW!

master chief sig - 7/10 a bit chaotic.

Commented on that on before. The text one I love though, great colors and outlining. Looks as if you overlayed your vert sig, but it's hot man. 9/10

8/10

7.5/10

Small and square, just like your personality. Baboosh.

7.6/10

hmm
6/10

not feeling it sorry

id hav to say 8.5 to john, love the way he fades off to the left

6/10 looks too filtered and not blended enough.

1st one, ggood smudging effects, to me i feel the render is out of place, the space between his arm and cape on the right looks like a blob to me. 6.5/10

But it's definitely not a bad sig. Could use some text

Too chaotic IMO.There's also no text.Miss that.
Good blending :)
7/10

5/10. Stock art with tutorials followed verbatim. Doesn't really show a personal style. However, the execution is pretty good.

7/10

7/10

6/10

5/10. Looks a bit too low quality. :S

5/10 Looks really bad imo. Not liking the scan line effect, or the mosaic tile things. Sorry :S
5/10 Nice smuding but once again not liking the scan lines and it looks like you didn't do much to the actual render.

7.5, simple background, but the lighting and effects are really well done. The render blends into them nicely. The effects near the text just seem a little too cluttered and pixely to me though, making it hard to read the word "splint". I wouldn't be able to read it if I didn't look at your username first. It's just that one area of bright turqouise that doesn't blend in with the other colours and the wording.

6/10

9/10 for both. That is if they were your own ideas. As you followed tutorials on both sigs I'll have to say 5/10 :S

9/10
Thats an awesome one!

4/10

6.5/10

5/10

8/10, I like the text.

6/10