Rate the signature above you.

7/10

5/10 nothing special, and to be honest rather boring... text is ok..
6/10 clean and simple, nothing special either but its easier on the eyes and the text is better, etc
7.5/10 i like the effects here, but the text in the corner is killing it for me and the border is white! :)

8/10
nice lightning
nice effects
overall great sig

Ummm 7/10 on the line art tag as you should try and add colour and shading into it and it would look 10 times better :D

8/10
9.9/10

Second kicks ass.

Mwuahaha collab ftw.

4/10 sorry man but looks like a c4d on either side, a render and some splatter/vector brushes. Not feeling it and the lightings really off.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Splinter.

Mwuahaha collab ftw.

4/10 sorry man but looks like a c4d on either side, a render and some splatter/vector brushes. Not feeling it and the lightings really off.

---

8/10

I dunno how I can improve the lighting, any tuts?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Reinkaos

8/10

I dunno how I can improve the lighting, any tuts?

---

7/10 like the colors of 1st one, but the render needs blending

mmmm the rest - are those sigs?

The first one is like damn! You rule. A bit monotone on the right side, your depth is almost perfect.
09/10

The second one can do with out the splatter brushes. A couple clipping masks would've blend it in some more but it is good. The light source IMO is in the wrong place. 07.5/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Takken

The first one is like damn! You rule. A bit monotone on the right side, your depth is almost perfect.
09/10

The second one can do with out the splatter brushes. A couple clipping masks would've blend it in some more but it is good. The light source IMO is in the wrong place. 07.5/10

---

1st - 7/10

2nd - 6/10

6/10
like the bg but the render doesn't blend with the bg work on lighting use burn/dodge tool or Filter>render>lightning to improve your lightning

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by funndoo

6/10
like the bg but the render doesn't blend with the bg work on lighting use burn/dodge tool or Filter>render>lightning to improve your lightning

---

7/10 not quite like that one of yours fundoo, the depth doesnt look realistic, the kids in BG should be more blured, and the front of the street should be less blured imho

9/10 for both. I think they're amazing! :) They have really good colours and i love the effects used on them.
xx

7/10

Shes hot, but the sigs quite smallish :) keep it up ;)

5/10 Really hate these kinda sigs :P
7/10 cool colors, shame about the lack of effects.

7/10 dorian <3

top one 10/10 definately :D rofl

and you know i love your bottom one :3

6/10 Too sample for me :/

5/10 too messy, i dont see any border, and the text is horrible =/
6.5/10

Lol borders fail, why is it compulsory to have one? You can't degrade him for it. Borders are old school and ugly :P

For the Fuzer one, 7/10. Good colors and whatnot but it's unoriginal.

cant tell exactly whats that sig. upside down give it 7/10.

10/10 Like everything in the sig,nice outcome with big height sig
10/10 Verry cool render,text,c4d and brushes
P.S My fav char in X-men :)

5.5/10 not a fan of your text and the lightning looks Fake
6.5/10 nice one, nice smudging

I see two focal there.
efects are decent. 6,5/10

needs much more details 5/10

I like them... But its like ive seen that style in too many sigs. :/

But still, theyre good! ;)
8/10
7.5/10

nice pop out sig, but could be improve and add some fx rate is 6/10. tho nice compo.

7/10 messy but nice effects, the B&W is the best

Gambit looks over topazed you ruined the texture of your smudging(so will be marked down) nice effects though 6/10

7,5/10

they all made very simple.
Second is the simplest I think. Blured Bg and C4D.
Sorry. Dont like them much.
5/10 for them

both i think are too empty..
no rating, wont dare

add some fx and scanlines killing the tag, 6/10

wolverine looks good. but why you keeping both versions?
7,5/10

Dont like secont one much.
purple is too bright.
6,5/10

black space on left kills it
7.5/10
Looks good black space though never mind
7/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NoFeaR

add some fx and scanlines killing the tag, 6/10

---

both?

Top is nice, text doesnt really do it for me. Could also do with a bit more effects. 6/10
Bottom would be awesome without the scanlines. Take it out. Also you should try blending the render more into the background. Also work with your text. 7/10 without the scanlines.

Nearly FHS but not bad, I like it, simple and the text is good. 7/10
Same here, but no FHS, GO PEDO. 8/10

(TO THE PERSON AFTER ME: YES. I EXPECT YOU TO RATE MY NAME BISH.)

Boring. Love the clipping function, gotta try to have my own text sig one of these days.
06/10

Dont like the effects much.
I think its over contrasted.
BG is empty. 5/10

A bit better, but monotony ills it. 5,5/10

empty on leftside extend the fx 7/10
blacky sig neat but not much eye appealing. 7/10

1. 10/10 very nice
2. 9/10 nice
:)