Rate the signature above you.

I find low quality because of too much of sharpen.
sorry, dont like the effects much.. 5.5/10

much better. good effects and stuff.. BG looks newbish, but it fits the stuff.
7.2/10 i think

8.5/10
9/10

8.5/10
9.5/10

not bad..
never seen something like that...
maybe too colorful??
6.8/10 now, if it would be made more professionaly and cleaner, I would give 8 or 9...

7/10
8/10 i like the colors in your second one.

HOUSE~!!!!!!!!!!!!!
7/10 B&W FAIL! and the colors on the right are out of place, lighting doesn't work at all if thats what that blotch on the bottom left is supposed to be...

07.5/10
08/10

I don't really like the smudging at all. I enjoy the outcome.

The 2nd one, I enjoy it alot more. Alot more life in it IMO. Sorry if I'm not making a proper critique right now. Just feeling lazy and I'm busy doing something else.

6/10 the circle around the text is a no go for me, and the render needs to be blended + text moved closer to him and smallerish
8/10 but text is still gettin on my nerves, so small >.> but good sig :)

oh, and there's no smudging in mah siggies :D

lq render. maybe some sharpen needed..
effects are decent.. 7/10

looks great. just i think its not finished.
bg looks very empty..
7/10 for now

9/10
9/10

7/10 nice composition.

I already rated your dragon one, but here goes.
6.5/10 I really feel like concentrating on the text more than the render, the text pulls my attention away. Plus I feel that there's too much going on.

8/10 text is improved! :)

7/10 a bit bland, but it looks nice..
8/10 nice effects, colours are good, seems a bit bland on the right.

7/10 for both

I see improvement :)

5,8/10
5/10

keep improving.
you doing it fast :)

8/10 kinda bland on the right, but good colours, nice effects.
9/10 Colours are nice, effects are ok, don't really like the render too much..

8/10 i like your style, colors could be a bit better imo

5.5
4.5

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TIGERsHAKER

5.5
4.5

---

whoa, what??? no offence.. but his tags are beast, i think we all generally agree on that..

4/10 dont like the text, bad stock, limited effects

Yeah seriously TS, I don't know what you think you're saying, out of spite or otherwise. Dron's tags are beast and he earned that. 7/10 for both btw Miril, like em both.

6/10 - interesting and different but some places look over saturated and lq. Also, the constant purpleness of it bugs me. Just personal preference.

ahh nice tag but i m not a fan of your clipping mask 7/10
and TIGERsHAKER i also agree with miril and DF Dron's tags are beast and i know him he is a gr8 sig maker

bit empty on right side, 6/10
non like it imo 4/10.

lol thanx guys for nice words :) i personally dont think my sigs are as "BEAST" as you say, but im trying my best to make them look such xD

well its his opinion, maybe he hates sigs of such style i dont care :>

as for above

7/10, not a fan of so many colors, but if you tried to make your sig as fantasy book cover then i would give 9/10, cos it would fit well :)

5.5/10 lightning is clearly off on this one and it dont have as good flow as your dragon sig, also colors could be better + i dont quite like the pentooling

left one - 6.5/10, the left hand side bugs me. Seems too dark and i think you could have incorperated some effects on the render to give it more flow

Right one - 7.5/10 - Better lighting and colour scheme works better. However, I do think adding some clipping masks e.g splatter or c4d's would enhance its depth.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Miril

whoa, what??? no offence.. but his tags are beast, i think we all generally agree on that..

4/10 dont like the text, bad stock, limited effects

---

i am attacked so much ,,, take it easy guys.. as himself said,i dont like this kind of styles but thats not y i rated low.. just no blending in the first sig and the second i do my best to focus n understand whats it about,,, fade everthing in the sig... as for mine if u rate 0/100 that wont bother me at all,it just a game nothing more,n u all do good job,least we learn from our comments,,, regards

right side looks great to me..
I'm talking about that blue stuff :]
dont like the copy of that black rectangular in the right side..
anyway. good stuff. 7/10

EDIT: too slow. :D that was for Active. :)

as for the sig above... 6/10 .... sorry guys for dorn`s sigs... am sure he is great sig maker or else he would not b on this nice good forum... but as i mentioned.. it just PROSPECTIVES ...and i like all ur works guys thats why iam here and learn for ya all,, once again,dorn its not personal,i dont know anybody here so peace man ;) sorry i rated the one before grais grais`s 9/10 9/10

5/10
Looks LQ ...
Just dont like the whole thing sorry :s

2/10 - didn't look like you tried at all
4/10 the c4ds are ontop of the render, which doesnt work. The colour of the c4ds doesnt blend with the BG, and the render isnt blended at all.

1/10 To simple and a ugly font with Italic.

7/10 Really nice, I like it. Good color comp and all the other small things are cool. The font isn't the best.

The waterworks thing isnt a sig, it's just a logo ;) Font was worse before, trust me.
8/10 for both, love em.

9/10 - love the effects and making it a pop-out was a great choice for this piece. Text could be improved, it's blended well just not too sure on it. :)

hmm i'll rate wolverine:p
i'd say 7/10 a bit bare, but nice.

8/10 9.5/10 i love them

4/10 it looks low quality, slightly oversharpened, theres no way of saying which one of 2 is your focal

lucky days - 7.5/10 - Good contrast. Could work on effects more and text. Lighting is quite good.

Hellgate - 7.5/10 - I think it could be sharpened a tad. Text is good, but I think it could also do with a bit more colouring..

Overall, decent tags.

6/10 dont like the text or repeated edge
7/10 nicee, that hair is insane, the right side is odd and ruins the flow imo, not a lot of depth, and the text is off to me

6.5/10 nice effects, and interesting features. However, the B&W seems a bit tedious.
6/10 good effects on mario got some flow going there. However, the text ruins it imo, and i feel there should be something done about the blackness of the bg.

Overall, decent tags.