Rate the signature above you.

rated first one already..
second one is nice too.
Dont like the stuff over her head(hat?) Bg a bit empty, so 6,5/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Garis

rated first one already..
second one is nice too.
Dont like the stuff over her head(hat?) Bg a bit empty, so 6,5/10

---

U mean her hair? lmao

top - 7/10 nice colours and flow. Text isnt that great :/
bottom - 8/10 - much nicer sig. Colour are great and effects are decent.

7/10 u cud add some other fx but just personal taste its great tag.
8/10 fairly like the siggy, tho bit empty on the rightside.

Hulk - Love the size and the effects but his purple shorts need to be sorted; 8/10
Kaliedoscope - It's not bad but I personally don't like the style; 6/10

I find your sigs rather plain dc. I'm somewhat disappointed. My fave was the Iron Man so I'll rank that. The colours seem nice with it though your sig size and the plainess ruin it.

6.5/10

getting better!!!!!!!!!!!!
7/10 text kills it, that blue doesn't belong there, cool effects
8/10 text!! always liked this one though

You know my thoughts and I'm pretty sure I know yours.

9/10 really nice sig. good colors. good flow. nice work dude. xD
http://img36.picoodle.com/img/img36/...2m_62bef19.jpg

vert - 6/10 - Not bad bg, but the render is not blended in enough and the text is not great. The pink border is also tacky.

Bottom - 7/10 - Nice bg and use of effects. Take away that blue border, change the text and fix the lighting and its pretty decent.

New one.. :)
I see same style in your current ones.
maybe if you would move focal more to the center, left side wont look so empty... 6,5/10
6,5/10 is good. I dont give much 8 or 9 or even 10 :D :D
so 7 is my most often using number here :) :)
good job active, keep it up :)

7/10 for 1st one, bit too much emptiness in the left and im not fan of colours that much

9/10 this one is SEX! lovely colours and effect

Not liking black one, dont know why 6/10( imo)
Liking the man! dont feel the box and text 'n' could use lightsource 8+/10

magna carta 7/10 the depth is off and the text is basic.
Mortal Kombat 8/10 the depth is great you nailed it, but the sig is too tall for the width of it imo.

I like it, not sure on the clipping mask next to his head, looks odd. 8.5/10

they all look very similar.
same style same canvas size, ssame effects..
sad, but GIF killed the quality..
6/10 for all.

Your always harsh about my pieces Garis. :(
It was a new style I was attempting as I have just learnt to blend and that so...
1st - I like it, good effects, text needs work in my opinion. 9/10
2nd - Similar, like the effects, good choice of render. 9/10

Hm. I dont think you will improve if i would say:
"good job, excelent, you mastered the PS 10/10"
I'm just being honest..
Being harsh is good sometimes :)
its good kick in the ass to improve :)

8,5/10 : cool sig ,but the left side is killing it for me
9,5/10 : I luvv that one , like the colours ,its very fresh nice job =D

Yes, we kick ass because we care. I already did yours earlier, 2/10 and 4/10.

The popout sig is nicely done. The colour and blending is good. Text kills it in away however.

7/10

dont like the first one much..
too colorful and there are too much stuff over the render..
BG looks randomed too much..
5/10

second is a bit better, but too monotone..
5.5/10

Love the top one. It has awesome flow, and the text is great. 9/10

The bottom one has great colors. Maybe a little too messy in some areas. I don't like the sky text green, when the sky is blue. :P 9/10

8/10 im really liking the fire fx, but i think its oversharpened, but overall a fitting sig KIU m8 :D

HULK 8/10 - nice effects and flow
Kaleidoscope - 6.5/10 Could use some effects to give it more flow, text could be improved too.

7/10 quite a mess there, thogh the effects are going with the flow and love the splatters, tone down the splatter and it did be sex

ahh buu, you've had thos forever.
7/10 top
8/10 bottom love that one.

I'm liking the colours you used and the pen tool skill (If that is what it is) I think the the text adds a touch and shadowing is on. The flow is good, if not perfect. I really can't find anything to critic. 09/10

This sig is mono. The effects make up for it, especially the smoke and I enjoy that. The text is superb. But there is too much emptiness so that needs work on. 06.7/10

6/10
Too monotone and i dont really see what the render is supposed to be .. :p
A dragon ?Monster ?
Not fond of the pentool ..
--
Nice one ,also very monotone ..
7,5/10

6/10
I like the idea of a vector sig, but I think it's missing some effects. Also the composition is a bit off. Just try and add some more things to it.

7.5/10
I like the idea and the composition is good. Again you could've added some more effects here though. Maybe some nice light effects to make the focal really pop out.

6/10 text + too dark on left side and effect on her face, cool effects on the right

10/10 - I love it. Not a thing I would change.

8/10 It's good but doesn't compare to your first one. Text needs to be altered.

5-6/10 don't like the text on the second one and it looks slightly monotone, again don't like the text on the first but fx are good.

http://img3.imageshack.us/img3/718/audir8e.jpg

hmm the flow is nice and the effects are okay, but the colours are clashing!
If that car was silver it would look wayy better. any text?
6.5/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Active.

hmm the flow is nice and the effects are okay, but the colours are clashing!
If that car was silver it would look wayy better. any text?
6.5/10

---

8/10 for both.

I like. Please make a tut. :)

8/10
Looks good.

Hmm, the left person's back looks weird. I like how you did the text, thats cool.
Not really my style, looks a bit plain.
6/10

7/10 I really like the effects and the colors.

A bit too plain for my taste. 6/10

Jool when you rate a signature you need to do out of 10, like this - 8/10

7/10 - I kind of like the style but the render doesn't like right with a odd background (which is pretty good). I also don't like the text.

All a bit simple. 7/10