Rate the signature above you.

dont like the text and border..
but it looks really nice
7/10

Your signatures are very awesome garis, but I'm not too keen on the clip masks on them. 8.5/10, well done :)

Thanks :)
Intersting stuff, nice text.
just a bit too shiny for me.
BG is only smudged, so need something different. clipping masks or something
7/10

8/10 Nice one =)
Left side is killing it ..
9/10
Very good :D
I like the colours ,cool ;)

For the first one, the colours are good. Rather plain but it suits the sig. Your goal was achieved. 10/10

Jessica Alba. Normally, as a person I would give it 20/10 but as a GFX artist I can't. Loving the 'splash' effects on the front of the render. The depth is good though in the top left corner it seems sorta ruined. 7/10

superior... that's all i have to say :P

I said some words about your work in its thread.
so 6/10

text is awesome in the first one, and the effects are too. 8.5/10

second one is really nice, nice coloring but the tag would be awesome without the box on the right and bottom left. 8/10

Pretty bare and mono, some different colours and c4ds could get used in there. Text is lame. 07/10


I like this one very much. The colour is on and the text is good. The depth seems passable as well. 07/10

1. 6/10 Effects are nice just the render...
2. 7/10 Good effects but bottom right looks messed up.

too many effects without a clear focal.. try to get a little more depth

6/10

The overall effects are ok, but the render really needs to be blend in more. The text also needs some work. Imo remove the box and change the fonts

6/10 nice effect and colours, but way too much negative space

Would be nice if you could help me out on that part. I know my backgrounds haven't been good so far. Just pointing it out doesn't really help me :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sanbu

Would be nice if you could help me out on that part. I know my backgrounds haven't been good so far. Just pointing it out doesn't really help me :)

---

i would put some brighter smudging on the sides maybe to create some depth?

also some killer text would be coool :>

Ah k thx, will try that out. Btw the text is on her headband :) Maybe not that noticeable but that was intended to be blended in.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sanbu

Ah k thx, will try that out. Btw the text is on her headband :) Maybe not that noticeable but that was intended to be blended in.

---

LOL just noticed it, nice one imo!

7/10 Just don't dont like you render :s
8/10 Nice colours and effects :)

For the first one, the colours are good. Rather plain but it suits the sig. Your goal was achieved. 10/10

Jessica Alba. Normally, as a person I would give it 20/10 but as a GFX artist I can't. Loving the 'splash' effects on the front of the render. The depth is good though in the top left corner it seems sorta ruined. 7/10

top 6.5/10 its nice and all, but the lighting is real off.

bottom this one is real nice. 7.9/10

I rated yours a lot of times :D
so 7,32/10 for the first one, and 6,45/10 for the second one :D :D

8/10

8.4/10

All of them have great flow. Overdid it with the clipping masks though mate.

6/10 I like the idea just seems a bit to empty
8/10 A great flow realy keeping with the theme

Dont know how much you did yourself, but his one looks good...
7/10 :)

8/10 Love it, the render placement is great, nice colours, text is awesome
10/10 megan fox..

7/10: Nice colouring, text could be a bit better. Depth is also good but the focal is a bit of a FHS imo.

9/10: Nice and simple really. Great flow and depth. Colours and light is also nicely worked out. Seems like he's standing next to a rock, but those are just effects :D Good job.

Loving the colours, though some seem to be clashing. The effects are great however, the depth is really non-existant. 08/10

This is somewhat my fave from you. The motion blur is great, while the flow is on! I like the effects. Really simple otherwise. 07.6/10

9,5/10 Nice one !Love the clipping mask ,colours and effects =)

7,5/10 Cool ,a bit too monotone ...

4 can do better than stamp silhouttes
6 work on lighting and blending c4d's, with a girl its better if u use round and fractal c4d's explosins will ruin it

6/10 not liking the render ~.^

7/10 too centered? but i like the colours

i like Dron's stuff a lot..
dont know about the cross in the first one..
7/10

second one is too colorful and you used too much of topaz..
6,5/10

cheers

Lul. Garis. Pfft... too much topaz! :p

First one - 9/10.
Love your effects in this.
Text is appealing too. Simple use of gradient overlay, yet it is appealing.
Nothing else to say, but great work.
<3 Effects.

Second one - 8/10.
The background is immense. Different.
Like the use of patterns on the right of Megan.
I rated it lower because I liked the effects in the first one more.
Despite that, great work still.

8/10 love the effects,
cool colors, getting the render right into my ye
2 points taken away for text, its not like i dont like it but its too big n blocky compared to the sig

7/10 although its appealing and cool, i did say try some other text rather that that one,
seems i kinda hate blocky fonts :p

tHANKS :)
Love your first one..
of course I see way too much of topaz, use sharpen! :D I think sharpen works better than topaz :)

colors and affects are really nice there..
but BG looks a bit empty// and I kinda start feeling this style of BG boring..
so strong 7 or more :)

8.5/10 for both, nice job garis.

Glad you like my sigs, Garis ;)

8/10 Lovely colours and i like effect

6/10 bit monotone to my eye >.>

7/10 not as great as your other ones, very little depth from the guy to the cross and text is off
8/10 love the effects and the colors, ok text

6/10 effects are cool but im not feeling the text and the render seems squished.

7.5/10

6/10 old and LQ ;o
8/10 nice needed more though imo