Rate the signature above you.

The sig is boring. But for a text sig, I think it rather good. Like the "worn out" font you're using or w/e effect you used. Really goes with with word.
9/10

Your favourites been rated god knows how many times..
Your latest: 6/10; Not really keen on it, the random pink ovals at the bottom are weird, the text is pretty bad and I just don't really like this piece compared to your others.

Lol. I don't really hang out in this thread xD

Edging on mono, the splatter are decently placed, though I would some parts more to be honest. The depth and flow is good as well. The depth not as good, but it gives you a "sense" you know. Probably not, I'm really weird xD
9/10

the 1st one is awesome alot of effects and depth. xD
10/10
the 2nd looks cool but its too bright for me lol if it had a few photo filters to make it a lil bit darker i culd see all the effects better.
8/10
xD

3.5/10 colours are off, lightning is off and its a low Q

Very nice stuff but very messy, I hate messy D; .
7/10 for desert eagle and 8/10 for the soccer one (damn, I've seen the guy but forgot his name)

6/10 too small
7/10 too small and lil work done

5/10

silent, you really need a new tag. That's been there like since I joined. :|
Anyway, I'll give it 8/10. I like the effects and text works well but don't like the rounded corners and would like to see something else added. I'm not sure what. :|

My fave sig from you yet. The effects, c4ds you used and how you use them really brought the Rulk's power IMO. The text, hmmm, passes. The splatter, lose it. The depth is non-existent though. I'll give it 9/10. Not alot, but not alot wrong either.

Hello, I'm new to Photoshop (Ive been using it for a week now, and not too much) but Id really like to know some constructive criticism on my signature. I made it following Freek's Style Tutorial (known as Seemliss on this forum). Any tips and help would be really appreciated.

Thanks!

8/10 i dont like the black lines in the render

10/10 tht animation is awesum

1/10. I'm sorry but i really don't like it. I looks like the images on the left and the right have just been plonked there without any thought, and they don't really match the rest of the image. Also, the font is terrible.
xx

3/10 lol this isnt because i don't like the sig its cos A) it looks like she has a fish hook in her mouth so bed choice of stock and B) because of that really annoying square in the top left. Would also say turn down the patterned background.

4/10 - that light spot kills it, too vivid imho and effect looks kinda low quality mm

10/10

i like the tanks and soldier they luk gd bud.

2/10
its original but bad compostion needs alot of work

7/10 lol as i said before it looks like Mavins being crushed by crystal which i like but it looks odd (slightly, thats just me being petty though)

8/10 i lyk the light and da lines coming off him

2.5/10 you already know my views on this from earlier.

9/10 i like it :)

6,7/10

5/10 :)

.Innovation: Sry about that while I was writing the post u did as well and my post got posted before yours. 9/10 I like the effects very much, perhaps it could use some font? :)

dunno what style that is but it looks good text needs work but thats everyone lol

umm 7.5/10 lol color is lacking also :)

Hollow Ichigo has no colour. :p

UnDeRoAtH: 7/10
Feels like you are covering too much of the head with the effects and C4Ds. Your name is also hard to read due to positioning and colour.

Amazing, truly amazing, the whole image is full of effects however it doesn't look saturated. I like very much how the text flows very well with the image. A true piece of art indeed! 10/10 :)

6/10

hmm 6/10
i dont like the colours and the left side of the sig seems too empty to me

4/10 i am not feeling them imo.

8/10 Love this kind of sigs,the font its just for the sig.
2nd sig cant see :/

5/10 interesting piece a bit to random for me
7/10 I like the filters used and the green glows not to keen on the text

5/10 way too plain for my taste

8/10 like that fire effect >.>

8/10
Modern Warfare one rocks!

Well, I LOVE the colors and the band. rofl

8/10 Its a little empty on the side in my opinion.

7/10

Not liking the text in the corners, and the effects over the character could be better, but the colours and layout is nice.

looks kinda pixelated in the hair and... pretty much the whole image. But i am geussing it came that way so..... 8/10 :D

8/10 Like the text,the background is nice :)
8/10 same for text and back

I like the theme.Its something original.
Dont like the text though,it needs some work.
I will say 7.5/10