Rate the signature above you.

4/10 Contrast is too high, not a fan of the border.

6/10 nice c4d work and text

8/10, Really liking it, well done.

7/10 Like the effects,without the border will look better and cant see ya text

6/10, oo high a contrast
5/10 the focal isn't brought out enough, the text doesn't fit either

9/10

Really like the colors, suits him well.
Nothing is really wrong with it...
Boarder is a little large? haha

Thing that's bugging me that everyone has said about Scribbles work is that the borders too large; it gives it a comicy effect. D:

Anyway, your signature isn't bad, good use of splatter and C4D work, I would crop the right side a bit to get rid of the empty space and move the text closer to the focal. 7/10

Ahh I see it now.

1. Very nice, love the touch of orange. Text is nice too 9/10

2. Effect around the render is really cool, gives it a bubbleish look haha. 8.5/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Craftyyy

Ahh I see it now.

1. Very nice, love the touch of orange. Text is nice too 9/10

2. Effect around the render is really cool, gives it a bubbleish look haha. 8.5/10

---

8/10 dont feel the text and white area with text?? near it, other than that its cool mate ;p

The first one: 7-8/10. Needs more depth imo. Also the text drags away from the focal.

The second one: 6/10 Don't like the violet border. Never like anything but black or white though tbh. Also dnt like the C4Ds/Pen around his arm and again needs more depth.

8/10. Not much going on, but I think that's what you were going for.

The reds and oranges look great against the dark background.

Maybe a little something could be added to the right hand side? Other than that, great job

Hmm.... 6/10

The Bad:
I Think your Signature looks LQ. It maybe my Monitor, Idk.
The C4d To the right points the focal somewhere else.
The Text is really random, i think it would do alot better without Text, but thats me.
The Wireframe Kinda hidden in the background is pretty random Also.
The weird splatter pattern is strange (too his left)

The Good:
Somewhat Good Flow
Colors are OKay.
You dont have his head right in the center :D

I Think you Did Good, Not Great But Not bad. :]

7/10 bit too chaotic >.>, other than that quite cool colors

Left 10/10, I love everything about this sig, however what really catches my attention is the text, I like the font and how you blended it in and having that logo next to it really makes it stand out more, I love the background and I was just wandering did you cut that character yourself?

Right 7/10, unlike your other sig, I really dislike the text being used, however what I do like is what you have done to the arms using the pen tool and that alone really boosted the score, also the colour of the whole sig is perfect and this got you some marks too.

8/10
i dont like where superman is getting cut off.
but other then that good.

6/10

All I can say is for more marks, lose the text and make the blue a little darker.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by walshy277

Left 10/10, I love everything about this sig, however what really catches my attention is the text, I like the font and how you blended it in and having that logo next to it really makes it stand out more, I love the background and I was just wandering did you cut that character yourself?

Right 7/10, unlike your other sig, I really dislike the text being used, however what I do like is what you have done to the arms using the pen tool and that alone really boosted the score, also the colour of the whole sig is perfect and this got you some marks too.

---

aye this text was a request from friend, he asked it clear and sharp, and specially with logo :D and ye i cut it myself, but i dont have that stock anymore :<

btw theres no pentooling in that 2nd sig at all ;p

thanx for 10 rating, man :)

If there is no pen tooling then how did you do that?.. C4D?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by walshy277

If there is no pen tooling then how did you do that?.. C4D?

---

fractal renders mostly >.>

Guys, please try to include the ratings. I understand that you may have already rated each other's sigs and don't really want to sound like broken records, but I don't want to remove any off topic posts.

Dron: Both are an 8/10. The Decepticon one looks great with the energy effects, the colours and the filters. I also like what you have done with the Tiesto sig. I've mentioned to you how I like the effects, but the text is a great improvement. :D

8/10

I am really liking the colours used in this sig, but honestly i'm not really a big fan of the typography. Overall great sig XD

7/10

its simplistic approach is sorta cool.

sorry for spamm, nutter ;p

OnTOPIC:

1st) 7.5/10 <3 those unusual color scheme, there is some pixelated areas tho

2nd)6.5/10 not a fun of this style, love to see some mad effects :)

1) I love that so much. 9/10.

2) It's really good and well blended with the C4D's. I just feel like something's missing. 6/10.

3/10...Don't like the colors and the contrast is too high.

It doesn't blend in well and the background is just one or 2 C4D's.
Nothing much has been done.
1/10

Bland colors, render's edges are pixelated, text would look better if it were straight. Good effort 4/10

1st- 9/10 Love the blending and lighting, black and white looks good for this one.

2nd- 7/10 Very good lighting and color scheme. Flow gets a little screwed up on the right of the girl. The corners look a little fucked up to. xD

Awesome though :D

6/10 - I cant put into words but to much purple :)

1st - Not bad, but at the same time it needs a lot of work. Text doesn't work either: 5/10

2nd - It's alright, the focal doesn't suit the background. C4D's don't have any effect to the flow: 5/10

1st. Amazing use of lighting and great colors. 8/10
2d. Transformers FTW. Great use of lighting but kinda LQ imo 7/10

1st bg kill it, but nice effects 6/10
2nd thats cool 10/10

errrrm, yeeeh, er not sure what to say fo u lol hmm well i guess i give that a great big fat N/A

Great effects and nice lighting but the black areas are kinda emprty 6/10

1st one is really nice, I think the background could be better. :)
6.5/10

2nd one, Great colours, great text, I don't see anything wrong with it. :D
10/10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by λdam

1st one is really nice, I think the background could be better. :)
6.5/10

2nd one, Great colours, great text, I don't see anything wrong with it. :D
10/10

---

5/10 kinda dull text is yuck, has potential though :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Joekz

5/10 kinda dull text is yuck, has potential though :D

---

7/10
I like the effects , especially around the hand. Just wish it had colors D:

Not a huge anime fan but I really like the effects on the first, not sure about the background though and it needs a direction.. 7/10
Second one looks better IMO but the focus looks really sharp and stands out a bit too much for me, love the effects again though. 9/10

6/10

looks good but its kind of plain i like how the text has the butterflys in it tho :)

cute sig 8/10