Rate the signature above you.

9/10 I wuv it

8.5/10 renders too big xD
9/10 cool colors :D

the top one looks great, i love the emotion on the guys face and how it kinda plays out with the grungy look in the background. the sophistication of the flag plays out well too. the smudging on the flag looks great, but i feel like the sparkly things should have looked kindof like settling dust and covered a little more of the bottom of the sig, behind the object focus. i think it needs a boarder too, partially because the colour theme is so strong it could use a little bit of a finale and a dark red boarder might do the trick, or even simply black.
the botton sig looks pretty good, imo, there too much smudging in the background, not enough clarity and too much clarity in the foreground, the foreground and background need to have a little more blend to them. you've got a real good sense of keeping a strong colour theme, but i think you should try playing with more than one shade next time :P

nice drawing and concept 8/10

10/10-- its amazing, i love everything about it
7.5/10-- very nice concept and use of vectors, good text as well.

Cool medal too

6/10, pretty cool, lightning could use some work imo

8/10 nice effect and execution, its just i think light source is a bit too bright

7/10 good death sig just bit too bright
8/10 nice smudge and depth.

8/10 DD i like the gory effects but im not a big fan of closeups =\

7/10 for the animation ... id make it light up fully at the end cycle to reveal the whole thing briefly

4/10 - im not digging the whole shadow effect behind the sig, its too strong, its too monotone, not many effects to it, check out some tutorials !! :)

8/10
I like the smudging, but the left side is too empty IMO

5/10 too empty and bad depth
7/10 text should be closer to him but has pretty good depth

7/10 - very nice, but no text, and the effects are minimal
5/10- the B/W version you posted is like 8/10 lol i just dont like the color match, personal opinion

i hate text
5/10 not a fan of typography obviously ;)

8/10..nice flow and blending
6/10..dunno why but it doesnt suit my tastes xD

10/10 I love that mario sig
9/10 colors are so good

9/10 - so cute :) but the right side is a bit empty
6/10 - no text, i just hate those colours

Not so much to it :/

1/10

5/10 not much goin on
9/10 ima sucker for abstracts :D

8/10 very nice
6/10 dont like the colors to much

8/10 i love anything affiliated with nature.
4/10 certainly not your best

9/10 at first i thought what a mess, but then i saw the theme and i really love it, the only thing you could have done lil better is to focus your atention on forward car more by doing better lightning, but i guess its ok as it is, just a thought :)

9/10- just awesome, everythings great
8/10-great effects, great lighting and depth

2/10, i'm sorry, i really don't like it. It's too flat and i feel like you should use more complimentary colours instead of contrasting.

5/10
6/10
sorry colors not working on my eye. NF

8/10
i really like you style
and i like the text in this one
it's a little bit too much blood for me XD
and the render is almost the whole sig.... a little bit smaller is better IMO
other then that great job :D

7.7/10 - love the effects, nice colors, nice text, to much neg space for my taste
9.2/10 - great depth, nice text, good effects

good work

9/10, i love it! Great use of lighting and colours, and the decoration around the side is virtually seamless. Maybe a thicker border though?
Great job :)

3/10 no real depth
4/10 just too messy

6/10 lighting seems to be a bit unusual
7/10 background with b&w is not that great.

8/10 - Good depth, good use of high and low saturation, little bit too sharp in places which destroys the quality slightly, other than that, great sig :)

7/10 nice flo but not really liking the effects or text

10/10 the render uis almost mixed great
2/10 it could have been improved


http://i48.tinypic.com/300r8gk.jpg

5/10 effects on her face is unecessary and its over-blended at the left side

9/10 - good flow. Effects fit well with the image
7/10 - Change the levels a bit just to bring out the whites and black to give it a bit of depth

7/10
LS too bright imo.

10/10 nothing wrong

10/10 I really like this one

7/10 could do with a little improvement

7/10 for spider man. the render could have been more mixed up i know u can do it

8/10 creed is good looking rays and the lightening effect is good. Text is't attracting IMO



http://i47.tinypic.com/28uqmpt.jpg

6/10
too plain add some depth, but nice focal.