Rate the signature above you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by starwar

yes it is for sotw. i also used multiple c4ds and a stock. u mind my cnc?

---

i gotcha, and of course i dont mind your cnc, and im glad u gave me your thoughts, i just gave u my thoughts on my sig, since it was such a low rating :)

and as for cs4pro

7/10 - nice flow, nice colors, however a bit messy, i think there is just too much in it lol, txt also needs a little work

6/10 - again nice flow, black and white isnt very good, however i know its for the sotw so..lol, the captain america txt isnt matching the sig imo

work on your lighting too, i dont see much of it in these :)

7/10 pentooling seems so obvious but nice gurl.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NoFeaR

7/10 pentooling seems so obvious but nice gurl.

---

ohh my fuck - its the French (i nicknamed this guy as such, when i watched the movie lol)
anyways 8.5/10 - everything is nice, but id like to see more of French's body not only his head:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dron

ohh my fuck - its the French (i nicknamed this guy as such, when i watched the movie lol)
anyways 8.5/10 - everything is nice, but id like to see more of French's body not only his head:)

---

for the first one i really like it, nice flow and depth so ill give it 8.5/10 as the lighting effect draws all my attention(dont really know if thats good or bad :P)

as for the second one ill give it a 7/10 good depth and blending but those lines on the sides seems a little bit weird to me, also the text is quite good :)

6/10 more fx can be added
7/10 bit empty on rightside and too much white

10/10
love the colors and comp :D

i Like the first one really much, except for the border but thats my taste i think this one is 9/10

second one is also very nice, except i personally like a bit more effects in it, so 8/10

7/10 kinda messy and text placement doesnt flow with the rest of the tag
7/10 too much empty space to the right

Kritez's gift is awesome. xD 9/10
I like the second one a lot too. I think the border around the render could be thinner towards the middle. I also think that the background is a little repetitive and could use some more flare. 8/10.

8/10 a great simple tag how to achieve depth from nothing.
9/10 almost perfect for me nice work.

I like the Idea of this one :D
there could be some more effects in the sig.
but it's pretty nice like this IMO
7.5/10

8/10 love the effects, hate the text lol

7/10 Render doesnt standout enough

7/10 for the first, it seems a little low quality.
i really like the second one, the render fits very well, but possibly needs some text? idk 8/10 :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Krunch_

7/10 for the first, it seems a little low quality.
i really like the second one, the render fits very well, but possibly needs some text? idk 8/10 :)

---

There is text in lower let corner :-P

8/10 Planet is a little too strong
9/10 very nice just too empty

6/10 focal is too blurry and its too plain
9/10 good use of the ripple tool

sidenote: dont rate my gift ;)

Nice background and blending the lighting is also really nice 10/10( i like it :P)

6/10 - Nice colours but it could do with a bit more depth and texture.
8/10 - I like it :) There is rather a large blank side on the right though which looks kind of out of place.

wowahh i really like the first one, i only miss one bit of color or something so 8/10

i don't like the second one much, just because it's a little blurry or something, and i can't figure out the text, but the colors are well chosen together so 4/10

6/10 it looks low quality
7/10 too messy imo
:)

8/10 depth is really nice however its monotone and the bright spot on the gun is distracting

10/10 The background + effets are really awesome. (One of the best i've seen for a while)

8/10 The text is average it could stand out more, his tuxedo look like snow (i don't like it) and his face is a little bit light, but i like the whole idea.

5/10 effects and render look lq and light source is acting as a second focal.
4/10 really messy and the text needs work

9/10 nice gift
8/10 nice composition pande, u cud add some bubble c4d i think but still tag looking great. NF

10/10 very very cool almost graffiti esk

wel.... i like the whole idea and how u did it, but its a little simple looking... not really my taste so 6/10

7/10 very nice but c4d's seem to be a bit too randomly placed

wow i really like this one :D especially the fading effect:D the only thing i can think about is that the text nees some work, so 8.5/10

The bg doesn't work with the render. The render needs blending. The c4d effects is just thrown in without any feeling, it's just there. Text is bad.

Since u got a high tech render I would go for a tech sig, so redo it all now ;)

3/10

10/10 (your sig)

My goal is to make something equal or better than that:D

7/10 too dark and over contrasted.

10/10
amazing

i like it! only thing that isn't really clear to me are the white thingey's nut it loos nice. i 'll give it a 9/10

not bad, but a little messy. 7/10

there is too much lightning.
I don't like the white dots on the left side of the sig.
But the flow is awsome... and some effects are really nice.
I like the text but i could be placed a bit closer to the focal.
8/10

i like both of them really much!! t
he first one for the effects and the second one
for the composition and the colors.
both 9/10

6/10 too messy and lighting needs work

nice 8/10. would remove most of the white stuff from the focal though

like it , but i think it's over sharpened in some area and i dont like the white dots
on the left side
6.5 /10

6/10 could be better with some more work. Lightning is too strong and distracting and bg is a little too plain for my liking.