Rate the signature above you.

9/10 i like clean but light is bright on right side

nice blending and lighting effect i give it 9/10 as it seems to me a little bit empty on the sides :D

I dont like the colors and the text in the firts one 4/10

The other one is much better i like the effects 7/10

7/10 effects are nice but needs work on depth and colors
5/10 too messy and distracting effects in the bg

it's not really my style :P
it's overtopazed.
The effects are very nice :)
8/10

Not bad, some blending issues and a tad monotone however nice depth;) 8/10
Hmmmm, again monotone, however not bad flow bg is a tad boring:/ 7/10

Try not to always stick to one colour or shade throughout, pick a pallette before beginning of abou 3-5 colours/shades and stick to it;)

logo is nice, cant tell what its for lol so, ill give it a 7/10

your sig is good, nice flow, good compo, nice colors, the copyright needs to be just a bit more in the corner i think, and i can c just a slight more goin on above the eye to the right, but thats my opinion, this is nice, 9/10

6/10 you need to blur that bg a lil more. also im not feeling the pen tool but everything else is nice

8/10
new looks pande :D

9/10- good effects, amazing color. not fond of the text, or lighting

great work as always nf

Hmmmm 8/10, the lighting is lazy although there is good depth , keep it up man:)

Huge ass sig :D

8/10

7/10 for top one
8.5/10 for bottom

Both nice lighting, love the complex simplicity of the second one though :)

6.5/10
very monotone and blending needs a lot of work, otherwise, good:);)

very nice for a big signature but it seems to me a little bit plain .. so ill give it a 7/10

4/10 over sharpened in some areas and over blurred in some areas. the text needs work as well as the colors

6/10- Interesting. But, it just lacks that "wow" factor for me, personally. And I'm not really too big of a fan of the text on the sides of the tag. Decent, nontheless.

8/10
7/10

just in med.

7/10 Too big for me.

Colors that don't match the render at all. To chaotic when the render is calmed. Text and blending needs work. Keep trying!

2/10

7.5/10
I like it :D I know it wasn't a render you worked with so this is a very nice result IMO.
Maybe I say that because I am not very good with stocks :p

8/10
Very nice effects, Great colors (I love blue :p) Text is ok.

Hmmm 8/10 Blending is way off, although everything else works well.
7/10 colours could be better, the render is doing all the work for you here.

Very nice Amazing Creative ! 10\10

7/10
8/10

nice stylish m8 kiu.

10/10
AWSOME.
Colors are amazing and so are the effects.
It has a good flow and the render is coooool :D

9/10 very nice effects and flow i like it
8.5/10 some nice effects but it seems a bit simple to me

6/10

the face is too vbright on front, though the light is coming from back. also i dont feel the text placement!

i like ur sig man!:D
8/10
but i was just wondering how would it look in color?

http://i45.tinypic.com/2hgzpu8.png

Cool i'd say 7/10

i think need more black places ^) 6\10

6/10 blending is bad and the lighting is very lazy. Sorry man:(

Way to big to be called a sig/tag. Like the retro feel and the watercolor look.

8.5/10

wow man, I like them both really much! But if I must choose i like the tech dragon one the most, perfect color and nice text man! as you can see i need some help with it -.-"

5/10
6/10

nice that u give my work a number, but you dont have any reconmandations (dunno if i spelled it right)? that would help me alot :P

i really like ur work! maybe it's a big too big for a sig, but the whole piece is beautiful! 10/10

5/10
cant see what it is.
There is no flow at all.
I dont see a lightning source.
text needs work

6.5/10
much better
Text needs some work.
Render needs to be more blended.
I do see what the render is and the effects are way better then the first one.
Also I see some lightning work ;)

hmmm 7/10 Blending is a big issue with you I think, you should work on it.;)
8/10 Great lighting, colours overall could be better and so could the text, although not bad:)

9/10 awesome piece, very creative. good job

7/10. It looks great, but could use some work. It is missing depth, and looks a bit flat.
The text doesn't look too good, but the colors a very nice.

7/10 - It looks good and all, I just don't really dig how it lacks color.
7/10 - Same situation. But I like the effects better on this one.