Rate the signature above you.

4/10 not my favorite, but keep trying.
There is hardly any depth, and the lighting doesn't look good. The colors don't blend
which makes it look pasted on. The text also fails hardcore, You should keep looking up more tutorials.

5.5/10 lq in parts, no flow, little compo and the left side brings the tag down big time.

9/10, love it.

http://i566.photobucket.com/albums/s...WitnessIII.png

Hmm...
4/10 on the first one, too plain, no name, but it's from V
3/10 on the second, again too plain, no render

Or....the one you posted! Silly me.

6/10, cool colours, no border, no text.

7/10
nyc colors.

6.5/10, I'm not too fond of the pentool and the contrast.


http://i566.photobucket.com/albums/s...WitnessIII.png

7/10
8/10
moderate one

How about the one I posted? xD
I like this one a lot. The only thing I would change is the clipping mask on the text, try to make it darker. Other than that, gj! 8.5/10.

http://i566.photobucket.com/albums/s...WitnessIII.png

the guys w/ eyeglasses is 6/10. try to put a little text :)
hehe :)

7/10 The left looks strange and some parts are over topazed. The text isnt too good.

7/10
interesting sig, i don't like the exposure behind the text

Can I see the original stock/render? If the original stock was just the guy then 5.5/10.


http://i566.photobucket.com/albums/s...WitnessIII.png

posted sig:
I like that, render is cool.
just needs some text. 7.5/10

signature:
1. Xould use some colors :) but the effects are nice IMO. 7.5/10
2. like the colors but i dont like that darker blue in the middle. 7/10

9/10 the Special text is way to big.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by oncore

Can I see the original stock/render? If the original stock was just the guy then 5.5/10.

---

It wasn't. More of an all in one image that made it incredibly easy to make a sweet sig out of.

2/10 for the one above me....you know why :P

lol I have to sy your sig is a 10/10 I love the colors and everything

Why you hatin on my baller sig? :-P

I like the font XD... you used the right letters F-U-R nice nice.
Nice border :) This is the work of a master 3/10 :p

9/10
nice fx+BG

The colors and text is spot on. Great lightning and effects. The render is beast. Re-he-he-he-eally liking this piece!

9/10

For your latest:

9/10 - I like the depth, colors and flow. Very nice on my eyes, I like it.

9/10

and the other is i dont feel so 7/10

first one is wow :)

5/10
need some blending and BG cud be improve.

pro sig :D 10/10

Really cool nice work with colors and really blends in.

9/10

7/10 could be blended just a little better and i dont like white effect that much, but overall - niiice:)

6/10, 8/10.

I like the consistent color themes between the sigs :)

8/10
8/10

nice colors.

*See what I wrote earlier*

9/10

8/10 nice effects but its over sharpened
8/10 not feeling the text but i like everything else :D

6/10 do not like it not ur style.

The render blends in nicely with the background/text overall really cool.
It is a tad dark other than that i couldnt find anything else wrong,
10/10-text
10/10-render
GJ

5.5/10 so many oversharpened things and colors are kinda bland :/

1st one is better than 2nd effect/blending-wise i may give it 6.5 :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dron

5.5/10 so many oversharpened things and colors are kinda bland :/

1st one is better than 2nd effect/blending-wise i may give it 6.5 :)

---

10/10 for kratos one :D but other one eh... 8/10 :D

7/10 too much aqua stuff IMO

5/10 too wide and not really anything going on in the tag at all keep workin man

5/10 not bad although it's too saturated and the lighting and depth need a lot of work .

Ehrm, medal, text.

Gonna give Pet a 10 for the medal :)

8/10
9.5/10 :) I just cant give perfect, but it is damn near it.

9/10
and
8/10
i lyk the blending of colors in th 1st one:D
NYc work.

8/10
nice tag, i like the effects around render, g w.