Rate the signature above you.

7/10. Text needs some tweaking

1.
Colors are nice :)
But there are not so much effects.
Text needs work.
7/10

2.
I really dont like the colors here and it;s too simple IMO.
Also the text needs work here.
5/10

9/10
good work!

6 and a half/10
text isnt too noticable(well...to me)
too bright around his face
but ovrall i like it
i also like the splatter behind him

4/10 too many conflicting layers, and the focus colors are too saturated, the highlights and lowlights are too similar to the color theme... it needs some more interest
everything just blends in...
the text needs work too
theres not enough flow between your layers
#2: 4.5/10
the focus is the car, and the green in the car should be your color theme, but you chose to use this pasty brown... blech... accentuate the green, and dont just overlay images, put some flow into them, blend the layers. there needs to be a line of motion too. it just looks like a floating car... and the background needs to be integrated with the foreground. one more thing: the lighting source is conflicting btwn the foreground and background

woo its good to be back...

haha 10/10 cause u do it urself :D

an average 8/10 on the two.
nice sprite tags:D.

hmm 6.5/10 i dont quite like the compo and overblured BG

7.5/10 for both:)

7/10 like the logo the rating is 7/10 because its monotome

haha, it's not made by me, it's the logo of a International art collective that I am a part of, lol/ (btw It doesn't matter if a logo is only one colour :) )

As for your tag 6.5/10 blending and lighting are letting it down badly, colours are nicely chosen though :)

wait... wheres your sig?
uhh i'll rate the logo then
i like the way it looks like a single fluid line and the quarter circle edges look good with the rest of it. i have no idea as to what it says tho... i can make out... r-e...u?v?i? [uhh...] n-u?

idk...

Its revuh.
10 / 10.
I like it and u draw these by yourself. cool.
GJ and amazing work.

9/10 :D

9/10
8/10 text doesnt fit
but u are good spriter :)

i like it a lot it has nice flow to it and the lighting is amazing i think the background could use a tad bit of work, so 9/10

Looks nice but that green pen tool isnt needed.
Looks to Messy.
Keep at it!:)

8/10 it's rather plain and the text next to owl city isnt readable. it looks like it's barely edited, but i like it n_n

id give it a 7/10
seems unfinished to me.
and the right side is oversharpened.
GJ on the sig:D.

1.
I like the effects
Text is ok.
Colors are pretty nice :D
8/10

2.
I don''t really like the right side of the sig.
Text needs to be moved closer to the focal IMO.
Colors are nice.
7/10

9/10 I dont like the small text, otherwise nice n w n

the thing behind his head is over-uh... i always forget this word... crap....

..::5 minutes later::..

SHARPENED
thats the second time i've forgotten that word on this site... fml
ahywho yeah that thing behind his head is over sharpened, and the text is a little to clean compaired to the object of focus which has a watercolor feel to it. and the eyes need a little color burn on them to keep them from being so bright
but i still give it a 9.8/10 cause i like it :D :D :D

I rate it a 10 because i self cant draw that well, and its just a really nice idea :)

1. id give it a 5/10
some over too sharpened areas.
and the c4d's at the back dont go with the flow.
and the smudge seems a little too bright. IMO. (lol, just knew the meaning)
2. id give it a 6.5/10
nyc concept.
but whats the point in puting bright colors.
in a soldier going to war (he aint gonna be happy).
id suggest put grunge effects. and put some flow in it.
and the guy seemed to just pasted in. blend im a little and add some depth (blur the bg).
Nyc sigs. fix these and ur good to go:D.
i knw u have potential:D>

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by renzAMP

1. id give it a 5/10
some over too sharpened areas.
and the c4d's at the back dont go with the flow.
and the smudge seems a little too bright. IMO. (lol, just knew the meaning)
2. id give it a 6.5/10
nyc concept.
but whats the point in puting bright colors.
in a soldier going to war (he aint gonna be happy).
id suggest put grunge effects. and put some flow in it.
and the guy seemed to just pasted in. blend im a little and add some depth (blur the bg).
Nyc sigs. fix these and ur good to go:D.
i knw u have potential:D>

---

I knew i was missing something i forgot grunge brushes

Oh and the soldier wasn't copied in its just a whole stock ;)

you can blur a stock image. apply image and just go to filter blur blur and erase parts over the soldier:D.

9/10 for the guitar one :D
8/10 for the girl on the guitar :D cause i dont like the lightning much

5/10

isnt this thread ment to give C&C..... so something more then only a number?
anyway nice kind of logo or something, im trying to make a logo for myself too, but it isnt quite working out the way i hoped. but i give it a 9/10 because of the flow.

8/10
Like it (:

5/10
5.5/10

awh.... when i was replying to itz shane i was too late :(
now its scribble again:P (its still nice though :P) maybe u got a tut or something that can help me with logo's?

6/10

can u at least say what u like or dislike? it helps me

7/10
change wireframes to c4d??

6/10 nO STRONG EFFECTS AND RENDER NEEDS BLENDING

Fur thats a sexy signature..
100000/10

#1: the quality needs to be better... the dude is like... blurry or something (just gonna say it could be my eyes they're fuckin me up lately - need new contacts) the red spiral doesnt really fit with the rest of it, especially considering that its quite clear and crisp and really quite... well i dont wanna say futuristic but i havent got a better word for it. against the old fashioned guy with a textured appearance, the spiral doesnt fit. you need some lowlights too, they're all mid-to-high tones in that thing. also get rid of the white opaque circle thingy up in the corner... i NEVER understand why people add those... they look so stupid.... makes everything look washed out, and if you're gonna do it then add a contrast color against the white to balance out the levels... just dont do it to begin with...

i love the position you've got him in and the blending of colors look pretty good together. the textured background against the guy looks great too - good blending of styles you've got there

#2: object of focus is too small compaired to the rest of the sig because theres so much going on. AGH get RID OF THE WHITE HALO OF LIGHT PLEASE
it makes things look so fucking washed out and weird TT_TT
text needs work
good colors again, and good placement. i love the wing thingy on the side... but... please just get rid of the lighting thing

SOMEONE GIVE ME A REAL CNC cause everyone's just like "i give it a 10 cause you drew it"
blarg i wanna improve too you know!!!

9.5/10

its really cool

hehe

kinda scary tho, thats why i take .5 marks off... lol :D

9.5
and
9.5
cause you're a pussy