Rate the signature above you.

first one is too blurry and clouded, the text isnt good and it's too monotone. It's like you just covered it up with smoke.
5/10

second one the text is bad imo and the smudging doesnt make it blend it just looks out of place. more effects would be nice and a better bg.
6/10

6/10.
A bit mono.
w8 i just commented on this. xD.
Face too bright.

8/10 Like the effects and the text, but it look way to messy IMO.
7/10 The bg look cool, but the effects don't do their "job"... more effects should do it.

8/10 Great job on the text and effects.. Looks very natural

8/10
You should clip mask the text. IMO.
to me, you should use a white border for light sigs.
Black doesnt fit.
Other than that GJ on the sig.

I've already commented the first one. 8/10 It looks awesome, but it's way too messy for me.
The abstract 9.5/10. Love the colors, the text looks great, but maybe a 1px border should be better IMO.

#1: 8/10 - I love the render (:)) I just feel that the transition between render and background goes a bit too fast around the leg area wich makes the entire dissapearing into the smudge look a bit "awkward", otherwise awsome.
#2: 9/10 - Just looks awsome tbh:)

8.5/10 - Flow is awesome and so are effects. Maybe text and lighting could use some work but its still damn good :)

7/10 Colors of the c4d/smudge look a bit messy.To bright on right side
8/10 LOVE THE SMUDGE! the c4d on his arm is Okk I lighting is to strong:)

1st: 8/10
2nd:7/10
I like them both :)

6/10 rofl!
The background is kinda plain, just render + liquid lol.
the font isn't very readable and vegeta doesnt blend too well.


Dont worry, my sigs aren't too good too lol...

Move text Closer to Focal
Effects look good
Read some tuts though;)

6/10

5/10 id change red to like blue or light green
6/10 Mmmm its a good quote, too plain of a sig for me tho

8.75/10 I love the flow and subtle effects!
7/10 Love the smudge work! colors are kinda bland (although i understand completely, assassins creed has that kind of blended colors theme) and it feels really unbalanced. Maybe a small assassins creed quote or something could fill up the gap.

8/10
A bit blurry for me and too dark.
Brighten it up a bit.
Love the effects and scan lines also the text.
would give it a 9.5. Just fix this and it will look AWESOME. xD
GJ on the sig. KIU

1st:
Effects are good,
The linez that go with text doesnt fit in da sig,
nice depth.
8/10

2nd:
Nice smudge,
That liquify effects ruined the flow,
text is in one word: "abstract" XD,
and yeah you done a great thing putting a movie border there.
8/10

A bit empty.
But the effects you made are nice :D
Lighting is cool.
Text is ok.
I like the smudge work in this one.

7.5/10

9/10

Love the effects.
Love the lightning.
Love the colors.
Love it!!..... but I don't like those clipping splatters... dunno why. xP

1st: Nice Depth!
Very Simple But Cool!
nice Lighting!
9.5/10

2nd:To Much White a bit mono
Looks Messy, to much Splatters
Renders looks a bit to sharp
Text could be better:P
7/10

6/10
didnt know what to really rate it lmao..just that it doesnt look appealing to me xD

7.5/10
Text isnt so great and the bar below it doesnt make it that much better, personally i think your bg looks the same throughout and im not really a fan of the blank space on the left. Lighting is good tho

1st: PERRRFECT! Love it
10/10

2nd:Nice SMugding
Cool C4d Usage on this one
Lighting is too strong though
8/10

Text! cant be more simpler than that ;)
7.26/10

and for the one that rates mine you can just do the lp or somethin in the pb

o.o text looks nice i guess 8.5/10

Bit to much Cntrast on this Chon
The left side of his face is too dark
The text could be better
:)
7/10

7/10 I dont like the font used, and the colors.
But it looks pretty nice nonetheless
:3

8.5/10 Kinda hard to tell whats happening but colors/lighting is great and so is flow. Could use some text :)

7.5/10
7/10

just ehh lol

8/10
There's something about the background I dont like, but otherwise nice :D

beautiful smudging 8/10

i simply loved it. it's hard to tell but there's something i didn't like with the sides of the signature. too dark maybe. 9/10 tho.. x)

first:
your watermark is too cornered and too visible imo. the bg is very plain and there's not much blending..
6/10

second:
the bg doesnt fit in so well, but it's far better than the first. i dont like the border, but that is for both. watermark is still too visible and the font choice is bad in both.
6/10

7/10

i dont see focal , maybe add some text... but smudge is nice :)

Nice Logo Design
I like and Colors
Text could be better though:)
7.5/10

pretty plain 4/10

bit too bright... text dosnt really goes with the sig and eh... plane bg... 4/10 i guess

Over Saturated
I like the Colors Though
Text is Nice
7/10
:)

plain but cool 6/10 :p

A little big for me, not to much done to it, and that random blotch of black is distracting. I do like the vibrancy of it. the text has a nice color and flow. Overall 6/10

7.5/10 A really cool simplistic design but the bg and edges of the render are just too contrasted/sharpened
8/10 got a great feel to it as well as lighting and blending but the text needs to stand out