Rate the signature above you.

wow aussi cool man nice tags :D
lets say 8/10 8.5/10 8/10

Ive said on another post i like this soo 7/10, nice colours and smudging, should add some more depth, tone down that lightsource and then maybe erase some of the sharpening :)

Good tags,c4d placement and colors are fine ^) 8\10

7/10 Some things could still be done with it but its pretty good.

Second one is awesome, becuase I assume you did all of the vectoring yourself? You can get a 10/11 in that case. First one is really cool too, it gets 8/10. I think that maybe the green text is a little bit hard to read, though I am quite blind =0. Would've been really awesome if it was your own photography, but really love them =D

1st: 8/10 Great smudging and colors, but that text isn't as great as it could be.
2nd: 7/10 I like the overall effect, but render blending and negative spaces could be improved.

first one I like the fact that i cant tell what u did to the stock if u added those nice fx or not
2nd one I dont really like it and its not coming across well for me

#1 nice but the text doesn't blend in- 9/10
#2 its just one solid color text is better but lacks depth and flow - 5/10

Great Depth
Nice Fx
8/10

do mine!
/E: 1/10 just writing.

Very flat, can see smudging, low quality, lighting is off, bad text and text placement and dislike the back shadow thing so about 3/10

The first one's a 8.5/10 epic lighting but that's all it is so no matter how good I think it looks I can't really rate it higher as a signature:)
The second one is a 9/10 as the lighting is once again insane and the depth is amazing.

ferry nice ;)

just looks like a brush with text 2/10

love the effects...flow looks good...wish there was a light source on the left side of the tag...7.5/10

6/10 Flow not present and the render looks LQ. Also the text and the person on the lower left distract from the focal... Sorry, not my favourite:(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by zole

Very flat, can see smudging, low quality, lighting is off, bad text and text placement and dislike the back shadow thing so about 3/10

---

seeing the smudging was part of the sig,
didn't come out to well, it was one of my first.
3/10
doesn't appeal to me, looks like a pic with a Filtered background.

Remove the text, too bright on the right side with no indication of lighting on the render, fairly good smudging.
6/10

8/10
little sharp
lol :p

5/10 I have a thing for dogs, not cats :D

1st@ 9/10 loving the concept there just not loving the bottom fx by the text other than that; perfect sig.

2@ 8/10 very nice but I think text sticks out too much.

6/10
its ok just a little plain and boring

muahaha

I LOVE IT!!!

10/10
(l)(l)(l)
<333

Text is bad.
Bg is to blurry.
The pixalate on the top left and bottom right is wierd.
Border is bad.
light source is on his face.
4/10

i like the lightning and how the c4d is blended up with the render and the smudge is good too i guess :D 8/10

@Newest
Dont like B&W or bottom left text render is a little oversharpened
6/10

meh 4/10, a bit messy bg imo and type doesnt match :O

Smexy even though you're missing yellow. 8/10

love how the render is blend up with everything :D and text is awsome too 9/10 :D

i doesn't like black and white butt 7,5/10

gotta love spongebob, I'll give it a 7/10 =)

Looks overcontrasted... 6/10.

8/10
Bad depth.

your latest is ok the render seems really outta place though blend it
6/10
favorite has little depth imo and is too blurred
4/10

8/10 love the colors in it and the feel of it
7/10 looks more like a tattoo design type feel and i dont really like it

8/10
Love the colours, but the BG seems a bit too hectic for me.

6/10 too monotone and lighting is kind of weak (doesnt resonate with the rest of the tag) decent effects. Good text.

I dont know what I like about it It just looks awesome.
Also very nice color scheme.
9/10

a bit sharp in the middle, borders ghey ;), i like the smudging in the bg

6/10

i dont see what the render is but i love the color 7/10

damn at the same time

ehhhmmm its onli tekst but its nice 6/10