i thinks those are pretty cool man. i think the firts one is kinda weird tho...just a little to dark
12-08-2005, 09:53 PM
Twan
dam youre getting better man. Those are nice! You sure have improved. OK.
1st- Not bad! it is layed out nicely. the background could use more depth, and try duplicating your render and setting it to overlay or hardlight or something to add more contrast. I would put antidote on the left of the line too.
2nd- Looks creative! I like the boxes with pieces of spiderman. I think it could use a bit more...something. Not sure what but yeah.
3rd- It could use some work but it's good to know you're getting more into "vector" style. The 2 lines kinda clash the way they are moving but it's not bad overall.
Good work! keey trying. If you look in the graphic discussion board, in the thread, "post your first sig" or something....you will see how bad I used to be man haha ;)
EDIT: screw what i said about the first one in duplicating and setting the blendmode, it looks fine.,
12-08-2005, 09:54 PM
DrksYd665
thay are all pretty kewl but ya kno i like the first one the best it jus looks evil
12-08-2005, 10:11 PM
CoŃ0
Realy, nice work... i like so much the spiderman sing...:D
12-08-2005, 10:44 PM
masokist
ok, i prolly sound completely different from everyone else, but. .
i like the first the best, except for the text, that could use a little work. my suggestion, have the line do a solid to fade kinda thing, rather than a fade solid fade. and have the solid underneath the bulk of text. an i would even say lose the underneath text, or make it just a tad smaller and less promiment.
the second one is good, i just have never been keen on the repeating backgrounds of that sort. but the boxes are extremely creative and i do commend you for those. looks pretty cool
and the second is fun, looks creative, but maybe lose the kinda glowy effect it all has, expecially where it overlaps. otherwise its quite creative and fun. good job.
i am sure you didnt want to read another essay after Twan's, but maybe you will take some of these into consideration and they may help, or jsut trash it and move on :P
12-08-2005, 11:48 PM
Rorin
the second one is the only one worth looking at in my opinion.... it was very well done, the other 2 kinda look thrown together
12-09-2005, 04:24 AM
Daywalker
second and third for me m8 very well done, i luv the spiddy sig.
12-09-2005, 10:24 AM
AntidotexXx
Thanks everyone for their c+c, i think that the first one needs a text makeover but i dont know what to do with it, should i use arial or some cool weird dafont text?
Suggestions are welcome.
12-09-2005, 10:29 AM
Rorin
play with the AA on it, maybe change the font size.... it looks slightly pixely
12-09-2005, 06:48 PM
Ben
1st- im not too keen on, too simple and doest work
2nd- just plain confuses me dont like
3rd i love it! its nice a simple but still looks great, the colours look nice :P OH NOES THE PINK IS SUCKING ME IN !!!
12-09-2005, 08:09 PM
nazgul
love the first 1...dont kno why must just be the way i like sigs