not too keen on anime but the bgs are good apart from the 2nd
the font effects etc arent that good but they alright
overall 7.3/10 ( dont wory that means they good with me ;) )
03-11-2005, 04:47 PM
AcidGlow
My only comment is you leave too much open space. The rest is fine. Good work.
03-11-2005, 04:55 PM
MinorThreat
avg=7.0/10
they are kind of all the same
my fav=3
03-11-2005, 05:21 PM
robgasm
o sorry, my fav either 4 or 3
03-11-2005, 06:57 PM
angryjohnny
Really good work for someone who has only been working a few months in photoshop.. way better than the stuff I was creating in my early days.
I like number 1.. Not only did you do a nice job making her seem part of the background ( Nice blending job ) but her demeanor seems to go along with the the background and whole feel for the sig. Number 5 is very good regarding the same notes I made about number one, And I really like the text you chosed " come with me" But I think you can do a better job with the fonts and look of the text.. maybe try and make it look alittle more hmm... Joyful ( just to go along with the statment).. maybe warm colors and enlarging the text so it makes more of a statment... and a little more color to the sig itself and I think you have another great sig. I like the sig you use as well.. has a nice feel to it.. Great work!
03-11-2005, 07:01 PM
jerner
I like the 3rd one, it's simple but goodlooking. Since you've only worked with photoshop for a couple of month I think you have done a good job, but as said, too much open space, (only on some of them) keep it up.
03-11-2005, 08:15 PM
Haven
guessing you don't have a girlfriend....just anime!....just kiddin...backgrounds are pretty cool..
03-11-2005, 08:35 PM
Nightfire
[One] I like the color blending with the anime and background, I don't really like the glow on her though. Animtaion on text is a bit skippy. Really like the border.
[Two] Like the anime you used, your background is good but since it's a background you could cut a part away and it would look the same(meaning repeated background) You should work on filling more space, like your text is small you should enlarge it a bit.
[Third] I really like how this one fits. Only text size bugs me, you should make it a bit bigger. I like though that you have a background that is a picture itself so not an empty looking area.
[Fourth] The background is a little to strong brushed? I don't know how to explain that. Anyway your anime pic just is way to smooth for the background. The text is also to hard to read.
[Fifth] Your anime pic looks a little streched sideways and the background you can barely see. I like the chose of text you used but I think you should have placed it in another place.
Overall I really like your sigs gj expecially for just a few months.
03-12-2005, 04:10 AM
2-intenze
i like the 4th the most :) :) :D good brushing and a good choise of the render :)
(8/10)
03-12-2005, 09:27 AM
Sumomo
@HAVEN
I AM a girl.... ;)
03-12-2005, 09:34 AM
Dale
They're al pretty good, especially the purple one. I like the bgs quite alot, but they don't all seem to fit with other parets of the sig/s.
Nice job
Overall you seem quite good - 8.3/10 , size is too big
